top of page
  • Cary Greene

Division Series Opponent: The Guardians!

by Cary Greene

October 9, 2022


This past Friday, when the Wild Card round of the MLB playoffs began, it seemed very much like the Rays would be able to sneak past the Guardians and set up a confrontation with the Yankees in the Division Series. However, if there’s one thing that a seasoned baseball fan comes to realize as time goes along, it is that predicting the game of baseball is extremely difficult. After watching Saturday's 14-inning marathon in its entirety, I have little doubt that Yankees fans are in for a thrilling Division Series against the Guardians!

After stifling the pesky Rays offense in Game One behind their ace, Shane Bieber and their All-Star third baseman José Ramirez, the Guardians were poised to break through and eliminate the Rays on Saturday and they did just that!

Though only the Tigers hit fewer home runs than the Guardians this season, Guardians rookie Oscar Hernandez clubbed a pitch he was looking for, a Corey Kluber breaking ball, over the 19-foot left field wall and into the seats to seal the deal and advance his team to the second round. The Guardians play a stingy brand of baseball that made for a very intriguing pitching-centric game-two matchup with the Rays. Unbelievably, the Rays managed only a single run in 23-innings against Cleveland’s stellar pitching.

During Saturday’s game-two matchup, a rarity occurred as it marked the first time in MLB history that a game was tied 0-0 entering the 14th-inning. Both the Guardians and the Rays tend to play tightly contested games.

Obviously, the Guardians calling card is their pitching. They have all the ingredients and given their team ERA+ of 110, so make no mistake, the Guardians stack up well enough, though a pinch short, with World Series champions of the past, who since 1903 have averaged an ERA+ of 113.31. Could the Guardians be the team no one saw coming out of the American League? Well, to stake that claim, they’ll have to focus on dismissing one opponent at a time and with the Rays safely kiboshed, it's time for the upstart Guardians to take on the vaunted Yankees.

Having punched their ticket to the Bronx this Tuesday, the Guardians are a ball club that this year stole the third most bases in MLB and also had the third best success rate. This ability to impact games on the base paths combines with their contact oriented approach and an unwillingness to strike out. The Guardians had the fewest strikeouts of any team in MLB this season (1,122). Though the Guardians aren’t especially good at drawing walks (they were 24th in MLB this season), they do make solid contact as they were sixth in the League in Hits (1,410) and 12th in On-Base-Percentage (.316). The Yankees will need to be very cognizant of these Guardians' strengths in the upcoming series.

There appears to be three keys to the Yankees beating Cleveland. The first is that the Yankees need to limit the Guardians gap-to-gap style of hitting and a rangy outfield configuration of Aaron Judge, Harrison Bader, and Oswaldo Cabrera may be helpful in doing just that. The second key will be to keep the Guardians off the bases as much as possible and thereby stunt their opportunities to deploy and maximize what is truly a devastating running-game. The last key is of course that the Yankees offense needs to show up in force and put runs on the board. If the Yankees can score in batches, the Yankees pitching will have far less pressure.

What the Yankees don’t want is to be lured into close games that drag on, from inning to inning, with very little scoring. Guardians gave up the 15th most home runs in the league this season (giving up 172 home runs), where as the Yankees offense was easily first in this department, as the Bombers slugged 254 dingers overall. A recipe for success might be for Yankees batters to hunt mistakes, as they did in the thrilling 2020 Wild Card series with Cleveland.

We can point to the Yankees owning a 5-1 record against the Guardians this season as proof that the Yankees are capable of advancing and having home field advantage in a 5-game series would seem to be another advantage that might tip the scales in the Yankees favor.

Lining-Up the Starters:

Considering that Shane Bieber pitched this past Friday, throwing 99-pitches, Guardians Manager Terry Francona may want to resist starting him on four-days rest to open the series. This could give the Yankees advantage number three, as Aaron Boone has a well-rested rotation to counter with.

Francona meanwhile may prefer to start Cal Quantrill in Game One to oppose Cole. Then, after Wednesday’s off-day, he will likely go with Beiber in Game Two and then after Friday’s off-day, he could deploy Triston McKenzie in Game Three as the series shifts to Cleveland.

If this thinking proves to be right, the Yankees would have a big advantage in Game One, with Aaron Boone likely starting Gerrit Cole. The Guardians are only batting .163 with a .243 OPS off of Cole this season so leading with Cole actually does make sense, but there’s two other reasons why I like the strategy.

In Game Two, the Yankees might go with Nestor Cortes Jr and then follow with Luis Severino in Game Three. Keep in mind, there is a weird “off-day” sandwiched between Game One and Game Two, and then another one between Game Two and Game Three as the series shifts from Yankee Stadium to Progressive Field in Cleveland. The first thing I like about leading with Cole is due to the way these off days are positioned, because it allows the Yankees to come back with Cole on regular rest for Game Four (in Cleveland). That makes things pretty tough on the Guardians if the series goes that long.

The second thing I like about leading with Cole is that, if necessary, Cortes might get the call in pivotal Game Five at Yankee Stadium, with Severino in the bullpen in an “all-hands-on-deck” situation. I have more faith in Cortes and or Sevy in a winner-take-all Game Five scenario than I do Cole for six-innings and then having to let the Yankees bullpen decide the series (nothing against Cole).

The Guardians On Offense:

Though the Guardians are basically a league average team offensively, with their team OPS+ of 102 being only 2-points above League-average, it’s a big mistake to think the Guardians' offense isn’t good enough to win it all. Keep in mind, the Braves, last season’s World Series champs, had an ERA+ of 114 last season (a bit better overall than the Guardians 110 this season) and an OPS+ of only 98, which was one-point above the 2021 League average of 97. Indeed, the Guardians are very close to having what it takes to win it all.

What the Guardians need is for their offense to get hot enough to provide enough run support for their pitching, which is absolutely coming together at the right time of year so far, to be able to suppress opposing offenses just enough to do what the Guardians like to do, which is to play close games and win the majority of them.

If the Guardians offense doesn’t heat up, they will likely struggle to score against quality postseason pitching, which the Yankees will no doubt have on full display. The Yankees ERA+ this season was 119 (third in MLB) and the Yankees bullpen has actually been coming together nicely down the stretch. Though the Yankees do lack a clearly defined closer, any number of Yankees' relievers are pitching well of late and Johnathan Loaisiga heads this list.

The Guardians squeaked past the Rays because of elite pitching. Each game was a typical, low scoring Guardians “pain-session” and also a typical low scoring Guardians game. Typically, the Guardians like to execute their organizational strategy of run-suppression, outstanding base running and timely hitting. Against the Yankees and in similar fashion, they’ll likely need to keep the Division Series a very low scoring affair if they plan on advancing to the American League Championship Series.

Due to the extra-innings “ghost-runner” rule being null and void for the postseason, if the Yankees get lured into long stretches of little to no scoring, the potential exists for some long, low scoring games between the Yankees, who hope their offense can prevent this from happening, and the Guardians, who are perfectly content to drag games on and on until they can manufacture the winning run.

Yankee pitchers will need to minimize the potential damage that Guardians All-Star third baseman José Ramirez can inflict. He’s clearly the Guardians' top offensive threat. Aside from Ramirez, second baseman Andres Gimenez (.837 OPS with 17 HR and 69 RBI’s this season), Game Two Wild-Card series hero Oscar Gonzalez, Steven Kwan and Josh Naylor are the most dangerous players in the Guardians lineup.

The Guardians Biggest Vulnerability:

One thing to watch out for is that Guardians were 12th in the league against right-handed pitching with a .717 OPS while being dismal against left-handed pitching, where they ranked 28th with a .646 OPS. This is a very significant stat that normally throughout history would spell impending disaster for a Yankees opponent, but Brian Cashman apparently doesn’t fully understand how important left-handed starters are to a team that plays home games in a ballpark that favors them. I’ll stop beating around the bush. I know Brian Cashman may have felt that Jordan Montgomery wouldn’t make the Yankees postseason roster, but it sure would be nice if he was around for this series as he could have combined with Nestor Cortes to form a pretty formidable mountain for the Guardians to have to scale. J.P. Sears might have also been quite valuable coming out of the bullpen, seeing as how Zack Britton’s comeback from TJS has been shut down. I’m not sure how Cashman could justify dumping not one, not two, but three left-handers at the deadline, each who could have helped end what is now a 12-year championship drought and counting.

  • Monty had a 3.11 ERA in 63.2 innings for the Cardinals, holding opposing batters to a .232 Average and a .656 OPS.

  • Sears posted a 3-3 record with a 4.69 ERA as a starter for the A’s but the Yankees were considering using him out of the bullpen down the stretch and right about now, he could be very useful.

  • Ken Waldichuk had a .493 ERA with the A’s as a starter and like Sears, he may have been valuable to the Yankees in the bullpen.

The Yankees will likely go with a bullpen that includes a few lefties at least, certainly Lucas Luetge and Aroldis Chapman will likely both make the cut. Granted, the Yankee bullpen has been ravaged by injuries this season, but since September 1st, the bullpen as a whole has been pitching a lot better than it was in July and August. What Will the Yankees Bullpen Look Like:

With 9 spots to fill here and factoring in injuries and ineffectiveness, here are the relievers, listed in order, who deserve a spot in the playoffs bullpen. Considering September to end of season performance, the Yankee bullpen will live or die with Jonathan Loaisiga, Scott Effross, Lou Trevino, and Lucas Leutge.

Getting Ron Marinaccio and Wandy Peralta back would be a big boost. It would be huge.

Given the lack of left-handness that plagues the Yankees' bullpen and factoring in that Chapman has been effective in September and October, and factoring in Jonathan Loaisiga’s increased effectiveness, it would appear that in order, Miguel Castro, Domingo German, and possibly Albert Abreu would be replacements for any relievers deemed unavailable.

  1. Lou Trevino - 2.53 ERA down stretch, team’s best bridge reliever

  2. Ron Marinaccio - questionable - 2.70 ERA down stretch

  3. Scott Effros - 0.00 ERA down stretch, might be used as the closer (per Boone)

  4. Clay Holmes - questionable - 3.55 ERA down stretch

  5. Lucas Leutge *LHP - 2.61 ERA down the stretch

  6. Wandy Peralta - questionable - 2.70 ERA down stretch but hasn’t pitched since Sept. 18th

  7. Clarke Schmidt - 3.54 ERA down the stretch

  8. Albert Abreu - only recently called back up

  9. Domingo German - 4.20 ERA down stretch

  10. Miguel Castro - 4.50 ERA in two October appearances, otherwise hasn’t pitched since Jul 10

  11. Jonathan Loaisiga - 1.72 ERA down stretch, may also wind up closing

  12. Aroldis Chapman *LHP - 3.18 ERA down stretch

Yankees' Keys to Winning the Division Series:

Limiting doubles will need to be the focus of the Yankees defense as the Guardians were 11th in the league at amassing two-baggers (273) and as mentioned, with an outfield of Aaron Judge, Harrison Bader, and Oswaldo Cabrera, I think the Yankees line up very favorably with the Guardians in the upcoming Division Series.

It may also make good sense to add another speedy outfielder to the roster in the Division Series and I anticipate the Yankees may do that if Andrew Benintendi is unavailable. Perhaps Tim Locastro would be useful for something other than pinch-running? I think he’d be useful if the Yankees find themselves needing to manufacture a run here or there.

Success in the Division series with the Guardians will likely boil down to five key things.

  1. How off-days will shape strategy. Cole clearly has the Guardians number. Can he continue his dominance over them? Meanwhile, Cortes is left-handed and that’s not good news for a team that struggles mightily against left-handed pitching. Can Cortes make two starts in this series if called upon for a decisive fifth game?

  2. The Yankees offense will need to break through against the Guardians superb pitching. It’s no secret, the Yankees hit home runs and Cleveland is a bit vulnerable to giving them up. Can the Yankees capitalize here?

  3. The Yankees can deploy a rangey outfield to minimize the line-drive “gap-power” approach of the Guardians. Will this stifle what is normally a successful Guardians' approach?

  4. Can the Guardians succeed against what is predominantly a right-handed Yankees pitching staff? If Cole and Severino pitch well, Cleveland will have to take advantage of the many right-handers in the Yankees bullpen.

  5. Yankees pitching will need to deal with the constant threat that Terry Francona creates on the base paths. Can Jose Trevino hurt the Guardians' vaunted running game? Trevino averaged the 9th fastest Exchange Rate (.68 seconds) among MLB catchers this season, but he ranked 52nd in POP Time to Second-Base this year (1.99) where Kyle Higashioka was 14th (.69 seconds) and his POP to second base was 26th (1.95).

Given that Trevino’s arm was rated 74th (77.9) and Higgy’s was 57th (80.1), it may make sense to give Higgy a start in this series but the Yankees will attempt to ride both of their catchers fast Exchange Rates while also attempting to keep the Guardians off the bases as much as possible.



Cary Greene
Cary Greene
Oct 09, 2022

The sheer amazement and disappointment of Aroldis Chapman's actions have sunk in for me this evening, I'm left distrubed and perplexed. This dude is 100% about himslef and no one else it seems! It feels like the Yankees decision to tell him to stay home might wind up being a catalyst for a team that has seemed to lack a sense of commitment at times this season.

It must have been hard for Boone to deal with millionaire players like Chapman, who are more focused on getting tatoos than they are being great teammates. Guys like Matt Carpenter, Jose Trevino, Harrison Bader, Nestor Cortes, Kyle Higashioka and all the others have begun to set a precedent - one that Aaron…


Cary Greene
Cary Greene
Oct 09, 2022

I'll reiterate (opposed to regurgitating) what I wrote prior to the Trade Deadline here and also paraphrase it. How nice would it be to have David Robertson, Joe Mantiply and possibly David Bednar right about now? Instead we have Effross (he's been great) and Trivino (hmmm, not bad I suppose). Doesn't seem like Cashman did quite enough, knowing Chappy was faltering badly AND injured and knowing Britton was huge question mark.

Thankfully Loaisiga found himself because without him right now, it's be a code-red emergency. Between Loaisiga and Effross there's a degree of stability remaining at the back end of the bullpen and if Holmes can be June Holmes, the Yanks are in business.

Cary Greene
Cary Greene
Oct 09, 2022
Replying to

What does make me want to regurgitate though is that the Phillies aquired Robertson but, at what cost? Many Mets fans were bummed by the deal also. Did Dombrowski overpay for a 37-year-old closer/rental player (Robertson)?

I, like Mets fans, wondered why MY team (the Yankees in this case) couldn't have offered more to the Cubs than what the Phillies did?? Was I asking too much of Cashman, wanting him to aquire Robertson??

Keep in mind, I wrote strongly this past offseason that the Cashman should have signed Robertson for the peanuts the Cubs wound up offering. He had a solid season. He's a proven postseason pitcher. He was one of the most inexpensive, quality relievers on the market last…


Cary Greene
Cary Greene
Oct 09, 2022

I remain convinced that the Braves, Dodgers, Astros or Yankees are the only teams capable of winning the World Series this season. I base this belief, as I have all season long, on the law of the 113.31 ERA+ (since 1903, past champions have averaged a 113.31 ERA+).

This season, one of these teams should do the usual (win). The Dodgers had the best regular season pitching in the history of baseball this year. But, they seem to have trouble with the Braves when the stakes are highest. The Astros have to be considered heavy favorites out of the AL.

As I always say, it's tough to predict baseball. We're almost at that point where we should know if a…


Robert Malchman
Robert Malchman
Oct 09, 2022

The front-loaded off days should be a big help to the stretched bullpen. Boone can have his most trusted guys available for Games 1, 2 and 3.

Cary Greene
Cary Greene
Oct 09, 2022
Replying to

I'll sign up for that, especially becasue that means the Yanks only have to face Bieber once!


Oct 09, 2022

HRs and relief pitching will be determinative for this series,

especially if Cole provides a game 1 W

Cary Greene
Cary Greene
Oct 09, 2022
Replying to

HR's certainly will be a big part of who wins. Both teams have very capable starting pitching. But - Cole is a problem for the Guardians, while Cortes is an even bigger one, then there's Sevy, who looks as good, if not even better, than he did in 2018 - which is problem #3 for Cleveland. Beyond all that, if this series gets into a battle of the bullpens, that would mean that the Yankee offense struggled to score agaist Cleveland's starters and the Guardians simply have a better bullpen than the Yankees do right now. Advantage Guardians in the latter scenario.

dr sem.png

Start Spreading the News is the place for some of the very best analysis and insight focusing primarily on the New York Yankees.

(Please note that we are not affiliated with the Yankees and that the news, perspectives, and ideas are entirely our own.)


Have a question for the Weekly Mailbag?

Click below or e-mail:

SSTN is proudly affiliated with Wilson Sporting Goods! Check out our press release here, and support us by using the affiliate links below:

Scattering the Ashes.jpeg

"Scattering The Ashes has all the feels. Paul Russell Semendinger's debut novel taps into every emotion. You'll laugh. You'll cry. You'll reexamine those relationships that give your life meaning." — Don Burke, writer at The New York Post

The Least Among Them.png

"This charming and meticulously researched book will remind you of baseball’s power to change and enrich lives far beyond the diamond."

—Jonathan Eig, New York Times best-selling author of Luckiest Man, Opening Day, and Ali: A Life

From Compton to the Bronx.jpg

"A young man from Compton rises to the highest levels of baseball greatness.

Considered one of the classiest baseball players ever, this is Roy White's story, but it's also the story of a unique period in baseball history when the Yankees fell from grace and regained glory and the country dealt with societal changes in many ways."


We are excited to announce our new sponsorship with FOCO for all officially licensed goods!

FOCO Featured:
carlos rodon bobblehead foco.jpg
bottom of page