top of page
  • Writer's picturePaul Semendinger

Perspectives: Put A Fork In Them...

by Paul Semendinger

August 11, 2022


I know, I know... It's August 11. "The Yankees lead the Major Leagues in home runs."

I know, I know. "They're right there with the Astros for the best record in the league."

Yeah, yeah.

Let's be honest.

Can we be honest?

This team is playing nothing like a championship club.


Since the All-Star Break, the Yankees have:

- Lost the series 0-2 to the Houston Astros

- Won the series 2 of 3 vs the Baltimore Orioles

- Lost the series 0-2 to the New York Mets

- Won the series 3-1 against the Kansas City Royals

- Lost the series 2-1 to the Seattle Mariners

- Lost the series 0-3 to the St. Louis Cardinals

- Lost the series 2-1 to the Seattle Mariners

That's seven series... the Yankees have lost five of them. The two teams they Yankees defeated were the Orioles and the Royals. The better teams? They are beating the Yankees.

These are just facts.


Since the All-Star Break, the Yankees, are 7-13.

Since June 30, the Yankees are 13-21.

That's not just bad. It's very bad.

It's not just very bad.

It's terrible.

It's a .382 winning percentage.

This isn't a small sample size.

It's just a fact.


Here's the big problem: We've seen this movie before. This is the same movie, the same performance, the same results, year-after-year for the last five seasons.

They're great. Then they're terrible.

There're terrible. Then they're great.

They cannot sustain the great play.

They cannot sustain the good play.

They fall into these deep ruts.

We have seen the Aaron Boone Yankees show flashes of brilliance for periods of time.

And then we see them come back to reality and become not just mediocre, but bad.

Great teams don't have bad months.

The Yankees have bad months, real bad months, every season.

And when they happens, the down periods seem to show how they'll perform in the post season.

Not good.


Aaron Judge is having the greatest stretch of his career.

And he can't carry the club. Maybe it is because there isn't enough talent around him.

Judge's greatness isn't helping them win.

I wish it were otherwise.


I know everyone says, "Judge will be back next year. He has to be back. He is the Yankees. The Yankees are Judge. He's the next Jeter."

I don't think he's coming back.

I wish it were otherwise.


Can I ask a simple question?

If you owned the Yankees, and if your philosophy was to always stay under that luxury cap, would you bring Aaron Judge back at the years and dollars he is going to command?

I think that if most fans were being honest, they'd say, "No, I wouldn't give Aaron Judge ten years." I don't think most would give him eight.

Will Aaron Judge be a $35m to $40m player when he is 38 years old?

I just don't think so.

Will his salary at that time prevent the Yankees from acquiring needed players?


If the Yankees stay with the model they're following, yes.

Will fans in 2029 or 2030 be celebrating Aaron Judge's 2022 season and saying, "It's ok that we're not winning, Judge was great eight years ago"? No, they won't.


I would be surprised if Aaron Judge doesn't get a ten year offer from some team or even a few teams teams. I wouldn't give him ten years. No way. I wouldn't give Aaron Judge ten years unless I'd be willing to spend whatever it takes each year to bring in great talent to surround him. But that's not the way the Yankees operate any longer. If the Yankees go BIG on Aaron Judge, they'll go small in other areas. If they do that, they won't be putting put the best team out there. If they don't put the best team out there, they won't be winning World Series during the "Aaron Judge Era."


Years ago, as soon as it became clear that Steve Cohen was buying the Mets, I declared that it wouldn't be long before the Mets became New York's number one baseball team.

Steve Cohen has been very clear.

He wants to win.

The Yankees have also been very clear, they want to win, but the luxury tax means more.


I know, I know. I can see the comments already.

"The Yankees will be able to have a great team and pay Judge. The kids coming up are all future stars. The Yankees haven't had talent like this in the minor leagues for a long time."

I have been hearing about the next bunch of great young stars for decades. When I make the point that that hasn't really happened since the Jeter era, people reply, "Yes, but this batch of kids is different. These guys, this time, are the real deal."

Just like Clint Frazier was the real deal.

And Miguel Andujar.

And Jose Tabata.

And Gary Sanchez.

And Blake Rutherford.

And Slade Heathcott.

And Jesus Montero.

And Jorge Mateo.

And even Gleyber Torres.

On and on...


I do know that there were reports that the Yankees talked to the Nationals about Juan Soto and said the words "Anthony Volpe and Jasson Dominguez" and the Nationals said, "Yeah, we're not impressed."

That's not filling me with anticipation and hope for this next great core.


I know, "Aaron Judge is the next Derek Jeter." I get it.

But Derek Jeter won.

Jeter's teams won World Series.

I know the comments that will come, "Yes, but Jeter had better players around him." Yeah, I get it. But if we give Jeter credit for being a winner, if he had some ability to make everyone around him better, then, that same logic and line of thinking for Judge has to also be in play. The Aaron Judge Yankees are bereft of a World Championship.

Maybe Aaron Judge isn't the next Jeter.

Who knows?


Maybe the difference is the manager.

Maybe it wasn't Jeter, but it was Joe Torre.

I don't think the 2022 Yankees have a manager who can right the ship. As the Yankees lose and lose some more, we keep seeing questionable decisions. We're seeing poor base running, bad bullpen management. (We're seeing more of what we've seen these last five years...).

Aaron Boone has been the manager for a long time now. He has many strengths. He keeps the Yankees in it. The Yankees win a lot of games year-in and year-out. But, I don't recall any writer, anywhere, writing, "Aaron Boone is a brilliant baseball manager" or "Aaron Boone is a great strategist."

I do hear that he's a nice guy. I hear that the players like him. That's not nothing. But I don't believe that he has the ability to find the ways in games to help the Yankees get an edge. I think he has good game plans to put into place before the games. I don't think he has good game plans in the moment.


I'll go on record here. If I'm wrong (and I hope I'm wrong) I welcome all the comments telling me how wrong I was at the end of the year. I hope the Yankees win the World Series. I hope they win the next fifty World Series. But, logic tells me that the 2022 Yankees peaked early and the truer 2022 Yankees are the team we've been seeing these last few weeks. It was great while it lasted, but it didn't last. It was unsustainable. The 2022 Yankees were not as good as they looked early this season. They're not reaching the World Series this year.


The Yankees will make the playoffs. But they won't get past Houston, and they might not even make it through the first round.

Maybe I'm just being pessimistic.


But, I think I'm just looking at the big picture, and, unfortunately, being realistic.


I also think that this was their last chance.

I don't think it worked.

I wish it had.

I think the window closes after this year.

I think some tough years are on the horizon.

It was fun while it lasted...


Patrick J. Sullivan
Patrick J. Sullivan
Aug 12, 2022

I understand the world is ending now, but I hold out hope because of the following: A rotation of Cole, Montas, Severino and Nasty stacks up very well against any of the other rotations. Offensively, DJ, Judge, Riz, Stanton stacks up very well against any of the other top 4 batting orders. Carp, Torres, Josh stacks up very well against any of the other middle of the order batting orders. Hicks, Trevino, AB, Hader/Locastro and Marwin stacks up very well against any of the other bottom of the order bats/depth batting orders/defensive replacements.

Holmes, Britton, Effross, Wandy, Chappy, Marinaccio, Luetge forms a solid BP. I would prefer game 7 vs. the Stros be at YS3, but history tells us that…

Paul Semendinger
Paul Semendinger
Aug 12, 2022
Replying to

I love the positivity.

I would love to be optimistic about this team...


Aug 12, 2022


Aug 11, 2022

I am not quite ready to throw in the towel…the Yankees have been battered lately but they are still standing. They aren’t as good a team that was going nuts in April, May and June but I don’t think they are as bad as they are playing now. They are somewhere in between the two. The competition aren’t really tearing things up (A.L. teams)…so I’m hopefully optimistic that they can right the ship. Not a Boone fan but he is the manager we are stuck with for now. Let’s go Yanks!


Cary Greene
Cary Greene
Aug 11, 2022

This type of article is why I love SSTN. The content here is real and not filtered with Pinstriped Lenses. Thank's for the read Paul! My general feeling is that Michael Fishman and the Yankee analytics team comes up with good data and it helps the team in some ways with the Luke Voits and Clay Holmes' of the world, but I think NY has been missing a Stick Michael "chief of baseball" GM for a long time now. Hal Steinbrenner is clearly passive, perhaps detached or just uninvolved/willing to defer..etc. More in a second...

Aug 12, 2022
Replying to

Hello Cary: yes, CP is back after a long hiatus.

My principal problem with this team is that it is NOT a team. After Judge, who are the winning ballplayers? Hicks? Torres? Kiner-Falefa? Donaldson? Even Rizzo is thinking long ball ALL THE TIME. I've spoken about this for years that the Yankees are a poorly constructed team. Yes, the defense has improved this season but they still strike out too much, make too little contact, chase bad pitches, and for the most part are very poor situational hitters. I've seen writers comparing the 2022 team to the 1998 team. Nonsense. The '98 team was very selective at the plate, took pitchers deep into the count, and were excellent situational hitter…


Aug 11, 2022

Oh or crying out loud. I am not a fan of Aaron Boone but this pining for Buck Showalter just drives me up the wall. Do any of you guys who want Showalter remember the 1995 ALDS? He completely mismanaged the pitching to blow a 2-0 lead in games and a winnable series. When he had Baltimore he left his closer in the bullpen and lost a winnable wild card game. He is not some kind of savior and even if he were the problems with this team go FAR beyond the manager. And Paul, Torre was not exactly a great in-game manager and he had better personnel than in the late nineties WS runs than this squad has. The problem…

Paul Semendinger
Paul Semendinger
Aug 11, 2022
Replying to

Right. I am not convinced that Judge wants to stay.

Freeman may have had the agent thing, but he's one of a long list...

Andy Pettitte

Albert Pujols

Ken Griffey, Jr

Pete Rose

Dave Winfield

Darryl Strawberry

Eric Davis

Barry Bonds

Greg Maddux

Johnny Damon

Mike Mussina

Jason Giambi


Robinson Cano

on and on and on... great players have left their teams for a host of reason (mostly $$$) but there have been other reasons also including ego, going home, players frustrated with the management, etc...

dr sem.png

Start Spreading the News is the place for some of the very best analysis and insight focusing primarily on the New York Yankees.

(Please note that we are not affiliated with the Yankees and that the news, perspectives, and ideas are entirely our own.)


Have a question for the Weekly Mailbag?

Click below or e-mail:

SSTN is proudly affiliated with Wilson Sporting Goods! Check out our press release here, and support us by using the affiliate links below:

Scattering the Ashes.jpeg

"Scattering The Ashes has all the feels. Paul Russell Semendinger's debut novel taps into every emotion. You'll laugh. You'll cry. You'll reexamine those relationships that give your life meaning." — Don Burke, writer at The New York Post

The Least Among Them.png

"This charming and meticulously researched book will remind you of baseball’s power to change and enrich lives far beyond the diamond."

—Jonathan Eig, New York Times best-selling author of Luckiest Man, Opening Day, and Ali: A Life

From Compton to the Bronx.jpg

"A young man from Compton rises to the highest levels of baseball greatness.

Considered one of the classiest baseball players ever, this is Roy White's story, but it's also the story of a unique period in baseball history when the Yankees fell from grace and regained glory and the country dealt with societal changes in many ways."


We are excited to announce our new sponsorship with FOCO for all officially licensed goods!

FOCO Featured:
carlos rodon bobblehead foco.jpg
bottom of page