top of page
file.jpg
Writer's picturePaul Semendinger

Perspectives: September 30, 2024

By Paul Semendinger

September 30, 2024

***

Well, now the post-season beacons.  It is time, way way way past time, for the Yankees to reach and win the World Series.


The Yankees limped to the finish of the regular season. It wasn't a good look, but none of that will matter when their playoffs start on Saturday.


Now, the Yankees just need to win games and series. It's the playoffs!

***

Sometimes when teams win games, I hear fans saying things like, "They really wanted it today" or they focus on players - "He was determined to win and nothing was going to stop him."  I never understand those phrases as words of praise because they actually imply that at other times the team or the player didn't really want it.


I've played enough ball to know that most players most of the time want to win.  Athletes do not play games to lose. And that's how it should be.  If I ran a baseball team and I had players on my team who sometimes didn't give their best, who sometimes didn't care, who sometimes didn't give it their all, they wouldn't be playing on my team any longer. 


As the Yankees limped to the finish, some people made excuses for them. "They don't need to win these games" and things like that. I don't buy the excuses. The Yankees lost their last two series, at home, while first place and home field advantage were on the line. The fact that the Yankees ended up with the best record was less because of their excellence, but more the fact that the teams challenging them kept losing.


Also, on a completely different note, and one that cannot be taken lightly, with the proliferation of sports betting, there should be a very real concern about sports teams that are supposedly (as some fans argue) not trying to win. The only way sports have any legitimacy is if the teams and the players on those teams are putting their best efforts forward and playing their best. It can be no other way.


Finally, the Pirates played hard. They were eliminated weeks ago. Again, that's how it should be. Teams must play to win. This is professional baseball. The games count. Every game.

***

All that being said, of course there are times when teams need to rest a player. Of course there are times when a player makes the correct choice by not crashing into a wall or diving into the seats.  (I made that point a few weeks ago.)  There are times when a pitcher needs to save his arm.  No player, not even Pete Rose, ran hard on every single groundout.  Sometimes you're just clearly out.  But in all of those circumstances, the desire to win and perform well is still there. 


This is a nuance I am afraid many cannot understand or will refuse to acknowledge.  In the end, these are professional ballplayers.  They should always be wanting and playing to win.  They should always be determined to win.  And they should always be giving their best. They won't always win, of course, but I want my team to be made up of players who are always focus on those ends, not just sometimes.  When one says, "He really wanted it today," it implies that he didn't really want it yesterday.  A team made up of players like that won't win. 

***

Anything can happen in a short series, but heading into any short series, I want the team I root for to be the better of the two teams.  Sure the underdog can win, but I always like my chances more when my team is the better team.


The strange thing about the 2024 Yankees is no one is quite sure if they are the better team.  On some days and for long periods, they look like an amazing baseball team - on others not so much, at all. 


There are fans that will say, correctly, "They won the most games in the league."  True. Very true.


Winning the most games means something.  And no team in the American League won more games than the Yankees. In a normal year, that means a lot, but I'm not sure what it means with this team.


This was a season where 93 wins clinched the most wins in the league. This is the first time since 2016 that no team in the A.L. won 100 games. I have said before, the Yankees this year were better than a lot of mediocre and poor teams. That doesn't mean they're good. It means they were better than other more flawed teams. A powerhouse they are not.

***

We have all seen Aaron Boone out-managed in big spots.  It's happened numerous times.  (To pre-empt the discussion in the comments, yes, I believe Aaron Boone makes the in-game decisions.  But, if it makes some people feel better, I could write this as "We have all seen the Yankees decision-making team out-managed in big spots."  The main point, in the end, is the same.)  


Boone has been the manager of the Yankees since 2017.  That's a long time.  There should never be a spot where he is out-managed.  He now has many years of experience. If he hasn't figured it all out by now, it seems clear that he never will. 


It's time to for the Yankees to be ahead of the other teams - to be the ones making the decisions in advance of the problems not in response to them.  For far too long Boone (or whomever) has been a step or more behind. 


The other night, Aaron Boone (or the Yankees as an organization) gave us, again, another example of how they do not plan well in advance.


On the TV broadcast on Friday night, after talking to Aaron Boone, Meredith Marakovits stated that the Yankees have only just started to think about how they are going to handle the week off this week.


She noted, "They might have some activities on Wednesday. They don't what that looks like yet..."


Now, note this is the YES reporter, the Yankees own reporter, reporting what the Yankees manager said to her, knowing full well that this is what she would share on the Yankees own television network. This was the message the Yankees wanted to give. "We haven't figured out what next week looks like," the manager said.


This is not a good look. Not having a plan is not a good look.


The manager could have said any number of things there. He could have said, "We have it under control." He could have said, "Our plan is not one we are sharing right now." There are countless things he could have said to indicate that the Yankees have been seriously considering the off week before they play in the playoffs.


Instead he said, "We don't know yet."


One key to success is planning. Not having a firm plan in place less than a week before the week off is very clear evidence that the team is not well-run nor well-organized. It's impossible to draw any other conclusion.


Any reader here who runs a business, manages people, has any responsibility in a job, etc. wouldn't accept that approach from their employees. At all.


It is almost impossible to fathom. A Major League Baseball team doesn't have a plan for the week off as the post season is about to begin? Really?


I am actually embarrassed for the Yankees that they'd admit this to the TV reporter, their own reporter, knowing that it would be discussed on air for millions to hear.


"Let them all know we don't have a clue."

***

We discussed the Aaron Judge day off enough. There are great differences of opinions. That's a good thing. Talking sports and making points is fun. It's what we do here.


But, some have framed the idea of Judge playing (had he played) as being selfish because he would be going after historic milestones. This line of thinking is new to me.


Was Babe Ruth selfish when he hit his 60th homer to set the record?

Was Roger Maris selfish when he hit number sixty-one?

Was Hank Aaron selfish for hitting home run 715?

Was Sandy Koufax selfish when he finished his perfect games and didn't let another pitcher get in the games?

Was Nolan Ryan selfish when he set the all-time strikeout record?

Was Rickey Henderson selfish when he set the single season and all-time stolen base marks?

On and on.


In sports the great athletes compete to be the best which includes playing in pursuit of records. That's why we keep track of them. Setting records and milestones is what great players and athletes do. It's what we celebrate. Those numbers frame our discussions forever more.


This idea that playing hard and accunulating milestones is being selfish is new to sports arguments. It's seems to be a call to mediocrity. "Don't be great."


I'll disagree, forever, with that line of thinking.

***

I'm not confident that the Yankees will win any of the playoff series.  For long stretches this season, they've been a bad team.  They played very poorly the last week of the regular season. And, again, first place and home field were on the line. They were absolutely. When people say otherwise, they're not telling the truth.


That being said, I can still see this team winning it all.  Anything can happen. By record, if nothing else, the Yankees are the best team from 2024 heading into the American League playoffs.


It'll be an interesting ride.  I hope it's a fun ride, a long ride, and one that ends with a trip down the Canyon of Heroes.  

***

Let's Go Yankees!

25 comments

25 Comments


Robert Malchman
Robert Malchman
Sep 30

I think there are games where players are extra-motivated. They are human and subject to human emotions. I don't think it's a coincidence that Verdugo had some of his best games against the Red Sox. There a reason "we can't look ahead" is a cliche because it is human nature to look past the A's to the Orioles (guess they succeeded there!). If the occasion and the motivation are irrelevant, why didn't Reggie hit three homers a game regularly against the Mariners, Rangers and other bad teams in the middle of the season?

Like
Paul Semendinger
Paul Semendinger
Sep 30
Replying to

A lot to digest here, Prof. The results don't necessarily mean the effort. Why didn't Reggie hit 3 homers in 1972 or 1978 or 1980 or... in the post seasons...


BUT... that being said (and I don't have time to dig in) - You Make Great Points here. You're making me re-think.

Like

yankeesblog
Sep 30

I'm sure that most, if not all, players always give their best. But their "best" on any given day may not be the absolute best they are capable of. Pitchers don't always have their best stuff so they try to focus on what's working for them that particular day and do the best they can that day. It's a long season for position players who are out there nearly every game. It's obvious that they are not going to be at their best every single game. Aaron Judge is trying just as hard when he strikes out 4 or 5 times in a game as he is when he's belting homers 5 games in a row. Some days you're the…


Like
Paul Semendinger
Paul Semendinger
Sep 30
Replying to

We were saying the same thing somewhat differently.


I think the Yankees did play hard. I also think they got beat. I think they put their best foot forward - and lost 4 of 6 games.


BUT, some fans excused the Yankees losses saying they weren't trying. Go back and read the comments from the articles last week.


They were saying the games didn't matter. They did. They didn't clinch until Saturday making Sunday's game meaningless as far as playoffs and such. The games did matter. And, I submit, because they're professionals, getting paid to play a game, and chanrging fans to watch them play, every game, even when eliminated, should matter.


Like

Alan B.
Alan B.
Sep 30

Between agents, the MLBPA, front office egos, and the financial realities, certain things are just put up with for a variety of reasons. I won't list them here, as that is a whole different discussion.


The problem is not really Boone in terms of being out manager, the real problem is that everything is based on analytics. Every damn decision, from lineup, pitching changes, etc. Sometimes baseball realities get in the way and affect it, but that is usually only affects who is available out of the bullpen for that game. Nothing is ever done by what they see with their own eyes. Boone is really only here to give Cashman cover. Too many other pointed questions would be asked…


Like

fuster
Sep 30

 some have framed the idea of Judge playing (had he played) as being selfish because he would be going after historic milestones.


what historic milestone?

what was there for Judge to achieve in the two games that he did not play?


If someone holds the AL record of 62 Hrs, is there anything historically noteworthy in having 59 or 60 rather than 58?


Like
fuster
Oct 01
Replying to

yes, Paul, 400 bases IS significant.


but it's not anything that is significant to very many fans, certainly not to casual ones or non0obsessive ones.


it's NOT anything that is generally noted. HR records, batting titles, triple crowns, no-hitters, and championships are all discussed by fans and even by kids,


I have NEVER had anyone "400 total bases" or even "total bases" to me


I've had total number of XBHs mentioned..... stolen base records brought up, but 400 total bases....never.


it's significant and it's rarely attained...... unless your name is Gehrig


thinking that 400 total bases is significant is true, but it's significant to only a few.


you might be the guy who would know if anyone has collected 400…


Edited
Like
dr sem.png

Start Spreading the News is the place for some of the very best analysis and insight focusing primarily on the New York Yankees.

(Please note that we are not affiliated with the Yankees and that the news, perspectives, and ideas are entirely our own.)

blog+image+2.jpeg

Have a question for the Weekly Mailbag?

Click below or e-mail:

SSTNReaderMail@gmail.com

SSTN is proudly affiliated with Wilson Sporting Goods! Check out our press release here, and support us by using the affiliate links below:

587611.jpg
583250.jpg
Scattering the Ashes.jpeg

"Scattering The Ashes has all the feels. Paul Russell Semendinger's debut novel taps into every emotion. You'll laugh. You'll cry. You'll reexamine those relationships that give your life meaning." — Don Burke, writer at The New York Post

The Least Among Them.png

"This charming and meticulously researched book will remind you of baseball’s power to change and enrich lives far beyond the diamond."

—Jonathan Eig, New York Times best-selling author of Luckiest Man, Opening Day, and Ali: A Life

From Compton to the Bronx.jpg

"A young man from Compton rises to the highest levels of baseball greatness.

Considered one of the classiest baseball players ever, this is Roy White's story, but it's also the story of a unique period in baseball history when the Yankees fell from grace and regained glory and the country dealt with societal changes in many ways."

foco-yankees.png

We are excited to announce our new sponsorship with FOCO for all officially licensed goods!

FOCO Featured:
carlos rodon bobblehead foco.jpg
bottom of page