top of page
file.jpg
  • Writer's pictureEthan Semendinger

Should They Stay or Go? (OF 2 of 2)

The Yankees have a lot of decisions to make this offseason, one could say there's bound to a "clash" of opinions. Let's talk about it.

 

Today I will be discussing some of the Yankees outfielders


Harrison Bader

2022 Statistics: 14 Games, .217/.245/.283/.528 (51 OPS+), 10 hits, 0 Home Runs, 9 RBI's, 2 BB's, 15 K's, -1 DRS, +4.3 Def, +1.2 bWAR/+1.5 fWAR

Contract Status: Has 1-Year/$4.7 Million Remaining on Contract Through 2023

---

Harrison Bader had a pretty bad start to his Yankees career. When traded for he was injured and wasn't slated to make a return to action until the end of the season. Add in some set-backs along the way (in addition to other Yankees injuries which depleted the team further) and the Harrison Bader experiment was off to a rocky start. This also isn't to mention that the Yankees traded a pretty well liked Yankee, and a starting pitcher, who was left handed (which the Yankees needed) in the deal for Bader...and that pitcher- Jordan Montgomery- went on to have a magical end to the season. It also doesn't help that once he got into games, Bader was a huge offensive liability and didn't flash anything incredibly special.


However, the playoffs did go a long way in fixing his image. He was just about the only Yankee hitter to show any power (which was strange in a lineup that had Judge, Rizzo, and Stanton in it) while knocking 5 home runs over the 9 games between the ALDS and ALCS. He was a rock star out there. And, he'll be back again to man center field for 2023.


The Verdict: I'll be honest: I'm not Harrison Bader's biggest fan. I think he's a fine baseball player and he's a huge upgrade over Aaron Hicks. I commend the Yankees for going to get a player to shell up center field for 2023. However, Harrison Bader should have never been that player to get. He's far too injury prone (much like Aaron Hicks) for me to want to believe in him as a player with a long-term future in the Bronx. He's a perfect middle-of-the-road center fielder for me. If I could take it or leave it, I would've left it. (And, this isn't against Bader at all, but I can't believe they thought replacing Montgomery (and Waldichuk) with Montas was a smart move...)

 

Oswaldo Cabrera

2022 Statistics: 44 Games, .247/.312/.429/.740 (109 OPS+), 38 Hits, 6 Home Runs, 19 RBI's, 15 BB's, 44 K's, +12 DRS, +6.6 Def, +1.6 bWAR/+1.5 fWAR

Contract Status: Still Under Rookie Eligibility; Under Control Through at Least 2028

---

Oswaldo Cabrera may have been my favorite Yankee to watch this past season. He was exactly what the Yankees needed when they called him up. He brought this incredible energy to team, was willing to do whatever it took to help the team (and to help the team win), found himself to be a fantastic outfielder while learning the position on the fly (he had the 10th best DRS across all outfielders with 250 innings played), and he hit quite well.


I even was willing put my money (and pride) where my mouth was to the point of writing in one of our Tuesday Discussion questions that if Cabrera was the ALCS or World Series MVP award winner, I would buy and wear a necklace like his for the entirety of 2023. Needless to say that didn't happen. (But, as he is going to be rookie eligible in 2023, I am willing to wager a Rookie of the Year award win on me wearing a necklace like him for the whole year of 2024.)


The Verdict: Set to become the Yankees rookie version of Marwin Gonzalez, I am hoping that if the Yankees are not willing to make huge moves this offseason that they quietly rebuild and allow Cabrera to make a name for himself as a full-time player. Giving him an offseason to work on playing left field would not be the worst thing in the world and it would allow him to have better versatility if the Yankees deem him to be their super utility man going forward. He became a fan favorite quick and the Yankees better not spoil his positive attitude for the game.

 

Andrew Benintendi

2022 Statistics (Overall): 126 Games, .304/.373/.399/.772 (120 OPS+), 140 Hits, 5 Home Runs, 51 RBI's, 52 BB's, 77 K's, +2 DRS, -3.5 Def, +3.2 bWAR/+2.8 fWAR

2022 Statistics (NYY): 33 Games, .254/.331/.404/.734 (109 OPS+), 29 Hits, 2 Home Runs, 12 RBI's, 13 BB's, 25 K's, +1 DRS, -0.4 Def, +0.7 bWAR/+0.8 fWAR

Contract Status: Set to become a Free Agent

---

A player that I wanted the Yankees to get at the trade deadline, Andrew Benintendi wasn't the best during his time in New York, but he also wasn't the worst. He was solid, but I can't say he really sold me on keeping him around now that he is set to become a free agent.


Through the first half of the season (before the trade deadline), Andrew Benintendi was lighting the world on fire while hitting to a .320 batting average. This was miles above every other Yankee (and before Judge hit to a a .380 batting average in September). Benintendi was also coming off a year where he won the AL Gold Glove and the Yankees needed someone to hold down a corner outfield position (this was before Cabrera made a name for himself). However, Benintendi got hurt after just over a month with the Yankees and was unable to make it back for the playoffs.


Now set to become a free agent while entering his age-28 season, there are questions with Benintendi. Do you bring him back? Do you let him go?


The Verdict: Andrew Benintendi has been an up-and-down player in his career so far. I don't know how much I'd trust him on a long-term deal if I was to pursue him in free agency. Obviously, I would offer him a qualifying offer for 2023. He's too young to want to accept that as an offer to have to prove it again. Then, if I was the Yankees and Benintendi was interested on a 5 or 6 year deal with an AAV of about $15 Million I'd start thinking about keeping him around. Benintendi is in a tough spot with Judge, Nimmo, Conforto, and Joc Pederson ahead of him in free agency, but he'll still get a solid deal out there.

 

Tim Locastro

2022 Statistics: 38 Games, .186/.239/.349/.588 (66 OPS+), 8 Hits, 2 Home Runs, 4 RBI's, 2 BB's, 7 K's, -2 DRS, -1.4 Def, -0.2 bWAR/0.0 fWAR (with 8 SB to 2 CS)

Contract Status: Still Under Pre-Arbitration; Under Contract through 2027

---

Not many baseball players can boast about having a Foolish Baseball video dedicated to them. Tim Locastro does (and it's a very fun video to watch!).


Locastro first became a Yankee in 2018 when traded for Drew Finley in November of 2018 form the Los Angeles Dodgers. He lasted until January 2019 when he was traded to the Arizona Diamondbacks for Ronald Roman (who never made the MLB) and cash. Then he was traded back to the Yankees from the Diamondbacks in July 2021 for Keegan Curtis. Then in November 2021 the Red Sox selected him off waivers and Locastro became a free agent before the month was over. In March of 2022 he signed as a free agent with the Yankees and for the first time he lasted a full season.


Locastro was a speed-only, baserunner. He really has no other role for the Yankees and he has no minor league options remaining.


The Verdict: Even if I wanted to keep around Locastro (who would be good minor league depth) I can't see him sticking around to be a minor league player for the Yankees when he may be able to get a deal elsewhere to stay at the MLB level. It's not impossible to think about (Tyler Wade just recently signed a minor league deal with the Oakland Athletics) and if Locastro wants to stay with the team as depth, I'd offer him a minor league deal immediately. He's a nice enough player and seems like a nice guy, but I'd also encourage him to get "the bag" where and while he still can and if he can't, we'll still be here for him.







10 comments

10 comentarios


Paul Semendinger
Paul Semendinger
03 nov 2022

The other concern with Bader is he is only signed through next season. He's not the long-term answer, unless the Yankees extend him (not a smart move consider the small sample size).


The great postseason that Bader had did not prove that he'll be great in 2023. It proved, only, that he had a great postseason.


But, let's remember, if we give him credit for the small sample size of his bat, we also have to note that he made two errors and made, as I saw it, two very bad throws overthrowing the cut-off man and second base. For a defense first player, those are concerns.


Bader, on the whole, impressed me, but we can't say, "What a hitter!"…


Me gusta
fuster
04 nov 2022
Contestando a

but while Bader is not necessarily the long-term answer, we should remember that the acquisition cost was quite modest.

the Yankees' cost was no more than an older player of slightly less annual value also on a contract set to expire after next season..


the team has all of this coming season to observe and assess a player who will begin next season at 28 years of age.

there is no 'problem' with Bader. he came at reasonable cost and he has replaced a 'speed-first' centerfielder more than 4 years his senior.


the actual problem was that the team wished to replace Hicks and had no other player on the roster or the farm ready to do that. they were…


Me gusta

Cary Greene
Cary Greene
03 nov 2022

On Locastro, I think he's just a below average player and a below average left fielder or center fielder and to compound this, he's a right-handed hitter. Why spend any money whatsoever on a player like "Lo-Castrol" as I once called him.


He served his purpose. He was an extra outfielder and a speed-chip. He certainly hustles right out of his shoes, so I'll give him that. But I'd rather see a real fourth outfielder on the team.


The Yankees have young outfielders in the system who are all still very far off. If it were up to me and the checkbook were opened? "If" Steinbrenner would approve me tippy-toeing right up the very edge of the Tier-2 Threshold, then…


Me gusta
Paul Semendinger
Paul Semendinger
03 nov 2022
Contestando a

I agree on Locastro. Move on.


You can't double-switch a DH. Which means that Stanton would have to come out of the game if you have him in the field. But, he can't play the field on any regular basis. He hasn't since becoming a Yankee. He's also hurt, a lot. And he's not going to be less-injury prone and also more athletic as an outfielder as he ages.


Stanton is the DH most days. Yes, he clogs it up. That's a problem with this team.

Me gusta

Cary Greene
Cary Greene
03 nov 2022

My thoughts on Benintendi. I'd love it if the Yankees signed him and I think the Yankees should sign him, but I believe he's the odd-man-out. The pressing need other than signing Judge may be determined to be first base, if Rizzo opts out. Perhaps the thinking will be, Hicks and or Cabrera can play OF.


Based on the projected budget left after hopefully signing Judge, the Yankees could barely afford a Starter or two and maybe Rizzo (probably not actually) as well. Buuuut - if Hal wants to go into Tier-One of the Threshold, then it would be easy to afford Rizzo. Any way you slice the numbers, WITH Rizz and WITH a couple Starters, "if" Hal wants to…


Me gusta

Cary Greene
Cary Greene
03 nov 2022

Good stuff Ethan, appreciated as always. My feedback is mixed on this group of players. With regard to Harrison Bader, the kid pretty much shut most of his critics up. I had no real opinion on the trade Cashman made to get him. I thought it was a strange trade, as Cashman talked about the playoffs and how Bader would be ultra-impactful once he recovered from the plantar fasciitus issue (I had a bout with this in my early 40's actually, but managed to get thorugh it).


Turns out, Cashman was very right, Bader did make a huge impact. He hustles, he plays with emotion and he seems to rise to the occasion as well. I'm actually fine with getting…


Me gusta
fuster
03 nov 2022
Contestando a

Bader's not a real centerfielder?


didn't the Fielding Bible peg him as second-best defender in CF in the majors for 2021?

Me gusta

fuster
03 nov 2022

regarding Benintendi

can the Yankees offer a guy that they acquired mid-season a qualifying offer?

Benintendi is a great fit for the team as a guy who gets on base often and who infrequently strikes out

he can bat lead-off and he can play left field well.

merely a question of whether he'll settle for a short deal at good money

Me gusta
fuster
04 nov 2022
Contestando a

I agree that it's gonna take more than $15M per to get a first-rate left fielder.

i have a glimmer of a hope that a different outfielder, coming off a poor year, might hit the market and be willing to sign a short-term deal.


Me gusta
dr sem.png

Start Spreading the News is the place for some of the very best analysis and insight focusing primarily on the New York Yankees.

(Please note that we are not affiliated with the Yankees and that the news, perspectives, and ideas are entirely our own.)

blog+image+2.jpeg

Have a question for the Weekly Mailbag?

Click below or e-mail:

SSTNReaderMail@gmail.com

SSTN is proudly affiliated with Wilson Sporting Goods! Check out our press release here, and support us by using the affiliate links below:

587611.jpg
583250.jpg
Scattering the Ashes.jpeg

"Scattering The Ashes has all the feels. Paul Russell Semendinger's debut novel taps into every emotion. You'll laugh. You'll cry. You'll reexamine those relationships that give your life meaning." — Don Burke, writer at The New York Post

The Least Among Them.png

"This charming and meticulously researched book will remind you of baseball’s power to change and enrich lives far beyond the diamond."

—Jonathan Eig, New York Times best-selling author of Luckiest Man, Opening Day, and Ali: A Life

From Compton to the Bronx.jpg

"A young man from Compton rises to the highest levels of baseball greatness.

Considered one of the classiest baseball players ever, this is Roy White's story, but it's also the story of a unique period in baseball history when the Yankees fell from grace and regained glory and the country dealt with societal changes in many ways."

foco-yankees.png

We are excited to announce our new sponsorship with FOCO for all officially licensed goods!

FOCO Featured:
carlos rodon bobblehead foco.jpg
bottom of page