Surprising League Leaders of the 1950s

By Paul Semendinger, Ed.D.

NOTE - This article was originally published by the IBWAA on June 7, 2025.

***

Over the last few weeks, I have been sharing lists of some lesser-known players who led their leagues in various categories from the 1960s and the 1970s. I began to wonder if there were some similar "one-year wonders" from the 1950s. Of course there were!

While the following players are not remembered as stars today, for one season at least, they were something special:

Billy Goodman, 1950 A.L. Batting Champion (.354) - Billy Goodman should be better remembered today. While he led the league in batting (or any offensive category) only once in his career, he had a lifetime batting average of .300 across 16 seasons. Goodman was a two-time All Star who also received MVP votes in six different seasons.

Earl Torgeson, 1950 N.L. Runs Leader (120) - Earl enjoyed a 15-year career, but this was the only time he led the league in any category. This was also the only time he scored 100 or more runs in a season, though he did score 99 runs in 1951.

Sam Mele, 1951 A.L. Doubles Leader, Tied (36) - In his ten-year career, Mele played for six different teams. He tied (with George Kell and Eddie Yost) for the league lead in doubles in 1951. This was the only season in which Mele hit more than 26 doubles.

Saul Rogovin, 1951 A.L. ERA Leader (2.78) - I would imagine that if someone posed this as a trivia question among baseball fans ("Who led the A.L. in ERA in 1951?"), Saul Rogovin would not be among the first 100 guesses, or even 1,000 guesses. In fact, I do not believe most fans have ever even heard of Saul Rogovin. In that 1951 season, Rogovin pitched to a 12-8 record over 216.2 innings. For his efforts, he received no MVP votes. He also never appeared in an All-Star game. Rogovin pitched to a 48-48 record over eight MLB seasons.

Chet Nichols, 1951, N.L. ERA Leader (2.88) - Nichols led the N.L. in ERA in his rookie season... and didn't even win Rookie of the Year. The award that year went to an outfielder named Willie Mays.

Dave Philley, 1953 A.L. Games Played (157) - They didn't know of OPS+ in 1953. And they also didn't know about WAR. For Dave Philley, that was a good thing. He led the league in games played in 1953. But, for his career, over 18 seasons, Philley accumulated just 7.9 WAR. His career OPS+ was 92. Philley was, for all intents and purposes, a replacement-level player, and yet, he hung around for all those seasons, playing for eight different clubs.

Bob Porterfield, 1953 A.L. Wins Leader (22) - Sometimes a pitcher has a career year. The most wins Bob Porterfield ever had in a season, other than 1953, was 13 (which he did twice). In 1953, he was 22-10 leading the league in wins, complete games, and shutouts. That was an amazing year for a pitcher who went 87-97 over a twelve-year career.

Don Mueller, 1954 N.L. Hits Leader (212) - 1954 was Mueller's only 200 hit season. It was also the only season he had more than 185 hits. His next highest total was 160. All that being said, Mueller was a better hitter than might be remembered. For his career, he batted .296. Mueller batted over .300 for three consecutive seasons (1954, 1955, and 1956).

Sonny Dixon, 1954 A.L. Games Pitched Leader (54) - Sonny Dixon's career lasted all of four seasons. In 1954, he led the A.L. in games pitched while pitching for the Washington Senators...and the Philadelphia A's. No, he wasn't traded from the Senators to the A's. He was traded from the Senators to the Chicago White Sox to the A's. The next season, he was traded (with cash) to the Yankees in exchange for Johnny Sain and Enos Slaughter. Dixon pitched in four games with the Yankees... and that was that. Career over.

Bill Bruton, 1955 N.L. At Bats Leader (636) - Bill Bruton should be better remembered. He led the N.L. in stolen bases three times, in triples twice, in at-bats once, and in runs scored once. In addition, he served as “big brother” to a promising youngster named Henry Louis Aaron. And yet, unlike that kid, Bruton never received a single MVP vote and was never was selected for an All-Star game.

Sam Jones, 1955 N.L. Strikeouts Leader (198) - Like Bill Bruton, more people should remember Sam Jones as he led the league, often enough, in various pitching categories. Jones led the N.L. in wins (1959), losses (1955), walks (1955, 1956, 1958, 1959), and strikeouts (1955, 1956, 1958). Jones pitched for seven teams over 14 seasons. He was not related to Sad Sam Jones who pitched for 22 years in the American League.

Don Elston, 1958 and 1959, N.L. Games Pitched Leader (69,65) - Don Elston was a workhorse. He pitched in 50 or more games for six consecutive seasons. He was an All-Star, twice, in 1959 (when the leagues staged two games to raise funds for the players’ pension fund).

(This is too much fun...)

***

Paul Semendinger has authored many books including From Compton to the Bronx (with Roy White) and The Least Among Them. Paul has also been published by SABR and the IBWAA on some great anthologies of baseball. He still plays baseball too. Thus far, he is 2-0 on the season as a pitcher in a 35+ wood bat league. He continues to wonder daily why the Yankees don't call him to the big leagues.