by EJ Fagan
March 11, 2024
***
NOTE: The following comes from EJ Fagan's substack page and is shared with permission.
Please check out EJ's substack page for more great articles.
***
If nothing changes, Oswaldo Cabrera is going to start the season as the Yankees lead backup infielder. How often do you expect him to play?
DJ LeMahieu is 35 years old. He’s going to rest occasionally, at least once per week. Ditto for the 34 year-old Rizzo. LeMahieu is set to cover first when Rizzo is out. So, the Yankees are playing their backup infielder at least twice per week, or 65 games year.
That’s a lot! Especially since Peraza is injured and Cabrera is looking real bad this Spring, hitting .043. The Yankees can’t afford to give away 250 PAs this year, before anyone gets injured.
The in-house alternatives aren’t great. Peraza is out for awhile with a major shoulder injury. Kevin Smith, Josh VanMeter, Jahmai Jones and Jeter Downs are all in camp, but all look like the Quad-A players they are. Jorbit Vivas doesn’t look ready yet either.
I think the Yankees are due to add someone soon. We know they made offers to Kike Hernandez and Amed Rosario a few weeks ago. Let’s explore some options.
J.D. Davis
The Giants released J.D. Davis this week. At first, my instinct was that it was odd to release a solid MLB player at this point in Spring, but it turns out that the Giants aren’t going to have to pay most of his $7 million salary. Unless someone picks him up, Davis will be a free agent next week.
His profile is pretty compelling:
Davis is a career .261/.343/.432 hitter. He plays mostly 1b and 3b, although usually much worse than Statcast’s 90th percentile estimate last year. Davis should probably start at 3rd base somewhere, although his defense may push him to a starting DH.
The downside is that Davis is a true free agent. Unlike other released players, the Yankees are going to have to pay most of his salary next year. He may want to be paid like a starting third baseman. He may want playing time. There’s a reason why MLB starters usually don’t sign on to bench roles. But he would be a huge upgrade for the Yankees if they could sign him.
Donovan Solano
How is this guy still a free agent?
Solano is one of the better bench players in the league. He’s 36 years old. He’s hit .289/.355/.405 since 2020. He can fake it at 2nd and 3rd and play a pretty good 1st base. I can’t imagine his salary demands are all that high, as he’s been a comfortable bench player for a bit.
There’s got to be some off field reason why he isn’t signed yet, right? Come on Yankees, Solano makes too much sense.
The Field
Amed Rosario and Kike Hernandez have one big thing that Solano and Davis do not: speed. The Yankees are pretty slow right now. They might want someone to run or do small ball pinch hitting off the bench. They might also need someone who can play shortstop.
It’s not clear to me who the third option is. Hernandez and Rosario wanted playing time. A trade candidate wouldn’t have real say over the matter. But no clear trade candidates pop out. The Yankees have made late-Spring trades before, but nothing is rumored.
I’m concerned that the Yankees are going to start the season with Oswald Cabrera and someone like Kevin Smith on the roster. One of the big reason that they are going to be better in 2024 than 2023 is that they aren’t expecting to give away hundreds of plate appearances to a bunch of below replacement level hitters. But right now, they are one injury away from doing it again.
