Tim Hill To Return

By Paul Semendinger
November 16, 2026
***
Those Yankees just keep making some big time moves.
When the Yankees state that they're focused on the World Series, it is clear that they're focused on watching other teams in the World Series.
Tim Hill was bad last year. His ERA+ was 92.
His strikeouts were down from the previous year. His home runs allowed were up.
Tim Hill's ERA has risen each year he's been in pinstripes:
2024 - 2.05
2025 - 3.09
2026 - 4.60
Not only are the Yankees bringing him back, they're so enamored with Tim Hill that they're holding an option for 2028.
Tim Hill also isn't a young guy with a bright future. He'll be 37-years-old next season.
These are the Yankees of today.
The reason I don't care enough to care very much is because the Yankees themselves don't care about being great. That has been obvious for years.














Let's just hope this doesn't follow recent off-season trends, where this is one of the few signings to restore most of the roster that didn't get the job done last year.
I keep hearing, "Hill is a league average pitcher," except... in 2026, he wasn't. He was a below league average pitcher.
doggone right!
this Tim Hill guy is nothing more than a league-average ground ball lefty reliever.
this aint exciting news and doesn't deserve to be treated as exciting. aint no big whoop.
this aint no party, this aint no disco
it's just business being conducted in a businesslike manner.