What a Difference a Year Makes

About The Off-Season: What a Difference a Year Makes
By Tim Kabel
November 19, 2026
***
Around this time last year, Trent Grisham accepted the qualifying offer the Yankees made to him. As a result, he remained with the Yankees for the entire 2026 season. A lot has been said and written about that situation. Many people, including me, criticized the Yankees for extending the offer to Grisham in the first place. Although Grisham had an uncharacteristically good year in 2025, the likelihood of him repeating it was slim at best. Well, I hate to say I told you so, but I told you so. So did a lot of people.
It could be argued that not only was the Grisham situation a total miscalculation by the Yankees but that it also set the tone for the entire off-season and another season of coming up short in 2026.
A lot of people believed that the Yankees miscalculated by thinking that Grisham would not accept the qualifying offer. He did. Many people thought that he would try to cash in on a long-term deal with another team, or perhaps even the Yankees. Well, considering that Grisham made over $22 million last year, he did cash in. He may have believed, perhaps correctly, that he would not receive a long-term offer that would be more financially beneficial to him than accepting the qualifying offer. So, he accepted it. No one can blame him for that.
Here's where it gets interesting. Many people believe that after Grisham accepted the qualifying offer, it tied the Yankees hands on making other moves. In reality, they did not improve the roster. They only brought back people who were already there. The Yankees had been linked to several free agents but the only major move they made in free agency was to re-sign Cody Bellinger. In all the areas where the Yankees could have upgraded, they did not. Was it really because they committed $22 million to Grisham, and did not want to add payroll? It's hard to argue against that theory.
Well, as many of us predicted, Grisham reverted to form in 2026. He only played 121 games due to multiple injuries. He batted .211 with 18 home runs and 59 RBI. His defense in centerfield, which had once been elite, became pedestrian. Grisham not only failed to live up to his $22 million contract last season, but he was also a disappointment on almost every level. Yet, whenever Grisham was healthy, Aaron Boone trotted him out to centerfield.
Having Grisham on the roster and in the starting lineup delayed the arrival of Spencer Jones. It stunted the progress of Jasson Dominguez, and it bogged down the lineup with an ineffective hitter. Not only did it bog down the lineup, but it also started the lineup off with almost a sure out. Just take a look at the last game the Yankees played this year, the 4-3 loss to Tampa Bay in the ALDS. Not only did Aaron Boone insist upon putting Grisham in centerfield, but he also batted him leadoff. Grisham had been on the IL from September 4th until the end of the season. In the playoffs prior to that last game, Grisham had two hits in ten at-bats. Both of those hits were singles. Yet there he was leading off the most important game of the season. Naturally, he went 0-5 with 3 strikeouts, including the one that ended the game.
The Yankees decision to extend the qualifying offer to Trent Grisham last year was ill-advised and ultimately, the wrong decision. It set a tone that adversely affected the rest of the Yankees off-season and the 2026 season.
Well, earlier this week, David Bednar accepted the qualifying offer that the Yankees made to him. He will be with the Yankees and will presumably be their closer through the 2027 season. The Yankees also have the ability to negotiate an extension with Bednar now that he is under contract for 2027. Unlike the decision to extend the qualifying offer to Trent Grisham, this was a good move. If Bednar had not accepted the offer and not re-signed with the Yankees, the Yankees bullpen which already requires a great deal of improvement would have been a disaster area. Although the Yankees really didn't do anything other than extend the offer, it sets a much different tone for the off-season and the 2027 season than the identical move for Grisham did last year.
The Yankees can feel good about the fact that Bednar will be here and will be the closer. That is one less thing the team has to worry about in what will most likely be a truncated offseason.
On the same day, the Yankees added Carlos Lagrange to the 40-man roster. Because there are multiple slots available in the bullpen, the re-signing of Bednar does not impede the growth or progress of Lagrange. In fact, if Lagrange does make the team as a relief pitcher, the bullpen will be much better. with both Bednar and Lagrange there. The Yankees still need to make some moves in the bullpen, but it won't be a major project.
It's funny that the Yankees made an identical move at the end of the 2026 season that they did at the end of the 2025 season. However, the perception of those two actions and potential outcomes and ramifications of the same action is vastly different. Unless something goes dreadfully wrong with David Bednar, having him on the team for 2027, at least, is a very good thing. The same could never really be said for Trent Grisham. In order for that to have happened, Grisham would have had to replicate the one good season of his career. That was always an unlikely scenario.
It is very interesting that the same move made by Brian Cashman and the Yankees a year apart could have such different results. Last year, it was a wrong turn from which the team never recovered. This year, it appears to be the correct turn that may lead the team toward ultimate success.














In reality they replaced the 22mil contract for the 23mil basically the same dollars different year... no cedit should go to Cashman. You need a closer and the Yankees have options for CF. This was an easy move for the GM!
It was a no brainer to make the offer or to sign Bednar. Now they must work hard to fill the holes in the lineup. FA or trade for 3B and do it now before the lockout. I would like to say get a good 2B, but i suspect they will go with Volpe the cheap option.