What the Yankees’ Retention of Aaron Boone For the 2027 Season Could Mean

What the Yankees’ Retention of Aaron Boone For the 2027 Season Could Mean

By Derek McAdam

October 21, 2026

***

After a disappointing end to the 2026 season, multiple reports said Monday that the New York Yankees are retaining manager Aaron Boone for the 2027, his final year under contract. It will be his 10th season at the helm, a managerial stint that has been heavily criticized due to the lack of World Series victories over the span. Boone also carries a 27-30 post-season record since 2018.

But there are several interesting points regarding Boone returning to the team next year. The first, and potentially most important point, is that the Yankees are likely doing this due to the almost-certain MLB lockout that is just six weeks away from beginning. There have not been many managerial openings this off-season because of the lockout speculation, since many teams likely do not want to make substantial changes before a season that may not possibly be played.

A perfect example is the Philadelphia Phillies. Many reports indicated that interim manager Don Mattingly was more than likely not returning in 2027 after the Phillies’ Wild Card exit. But several days after their elimination, the Phillies announced that Mattingly would be returning as the full-time manager through the 2028 season. How is it that we go from Mattingly is not returning to a two-year contract? It is more than likely the result of the impending lockout, as Preston Mattingly, Don’s son, figured it would make more sense to keep someone around that the players and front office are familiar with than try to hire someone else before a season that will at least likely not start on time at best.

Back to the Yankees and Boone, I think there is another interesting fact about the skipper returning next year. The fact that Boone has not agreed to a contract extension is fairly notable. Could this mean that Brian Cashman is trying to give Boone a hint that he has to make a legitimate run next year at a World Series? Or could it be that the two are simply not discussing any sort of extension until at least sometime next year? Either is a possibility, but I doubt Boone has been offered an extension and has no knowledge of when that will happen.

Here’s the reality of everything: the Yankees have a lot of changes that have to be made if they want to compete for a World Series. I have not been the biggest fan of Boone over the years, and while he definitely has his flaws, he is not the biggest issue in the Yankee organization.

Cashman is a much bigger problem than Boone. Not only did he hire Boone, but he has been responsible for the Yankees’ developmental team and any transactions made by the team. And sure, Cashman has struck gold with some homegrown players. Aaron Judge became a franchise player, while Cam Schlittler is set to win his first Cy Young Award and Ben Rice has taken tremendous steps over the past year. Not to mention players such as Spencer Jones and George Lombard Jr. are showing positive signs that they can be everyday players at the Major League level.

But Cashman also assembled a 2026 team that was in the bottom third of batting average, hits, and fielding percentage. And these flaws showed tremendously in the ALDS against Tampa Bay. But great, they hit a bunch of home runs! After all, Rice still leads all post-season players with four home runs, and he has not played in two weeks! It just shows that there’s more to an offense than relying on the home run.

And an even bigger problem than Cashman is owner Hal Steinbrenner. I will admit that I am not the biggest fan of just spending and spending every off-season, even though Yankee fans continue to criticize Steinbrenner on this topic despite the Yankees having a top payroll every season. It matters how they spend their money, and the Yankees have been okay at best with their big signings. They have some good signings, but some big duds as well.

For Steinbrenner, it is all about the money he is bringing in. Michael Kay recently said that Steinbrenner was “very upset” that the Yankees were swept in the ALDS. What exactly was he upset over? Was it the fact that he was swept by an AL East opponent in which they looked completely lost the entire series? Or was it that the Yankees couldn’t force a Game 4 so he could get more revenue from an additional game at Yankee Stadium? Because if it was the former, I feel as if changes would already have been made. Cashman is not currently under contract for next season, but it seems very likely he returns. As they say, the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results.

Kay’s report could also be a wake-up message to the entire organization from Steinbrenner, although I don’t particularly see it that way. I think Steinbrenner loves Cashman, because he knows the longtime general manager is going to put together a team that will make the playoffs one way or another. From there, I don’t think Steinbrenner actually cares too much about what happens. But even I think he is starting to sense that Yankee fans are getting restless.

Overall, for the time being, I’m having some optimism that change could soon be on the horizon. Am I holding my breath over it? Absolutely not, because Cashman is going to feed Steinbrenner an excuse as to why the Yankees didn’t go further this year (Judge being hurt in the playoffs, although I would not be shocked if Cashman left him off the post-season rosters purposely to have an excuse), which is going to result in Boone also having the excuse.

Hopefully, this is just a stopgap move to keep Boone because of the impending lockout and the Yankees weigh their options throughout next year. But only time will tell!