top of page
file.jpg
Writer's pictureEthan Semendinger

Looking at: MLBTR Arbitration Projections (1 of 2)

A little over a month ago, MLBTR released their arbitration projections for each team. Let's look and consider the cases for the Yankees.

 

Player One: Jon Berti (INF)

2024 Stats: 25 GP, .273/.342/.318/.661, 90 OPS+, 18 H, 1 HR, 6 RBI's, +0.6 bWAR

2024 Salary: $3,500,000

2025 Arbitration Projection: $3,800,000


Jon Berti was acquired from the Miami Marlins in a 3-team trade that was mostly made up on minor leaguers, but also sent Ben Rortvedt to Tampa Bay. Berti was expected to compete for the open third base role with the Yankees, or serve as another super-utility infielder with DJ LeMahieu for the 2024 season, but instead his season was mostly spent on the injured list. He suffered a left groin strain in early April (which kept him out until early May) and then he suffered a left calf strain in late May (which kept him out until early September). In the games he did play, he did a fine job offensively (his career OPS+ in 92) and he did a good job defensively. He also has plus-speed, which is nice.


Berti was on-and-off the playoff roster this year, and ultimately missed being on the World Series roster due to another injury (right hip flexor strain). He'll be playing in his age-35 season next year, and with 3 injuries in 2024, that is not a promising sign for his long-term health and availability. However, his ability to play anywhere in the infield (and in the outfield in a pinch) is valuable.


Would I Re-Sign Him? Yes. Jon Berti is a relatively low-risk, high-reward type bench player. For only $3.8 Million, I'd roll the dice for his final arbitration season. Let's just hope for better health in 2025.

 

Player Two: Tim Mayza (LHRP)

2024 Stats (NYY): 15 GP, 0-1 Record, 4.00 ERA (105 ERA+), 18.0 IP, 12 K's, 3 BB's

2024 Salary: $2,900,000

2025 Arbitration Projection: $4,000,000


Tim Mayza was designated for assignment and released by the Toronto Blue Jays in early July after posting an 8.03 ERA over 24.2 innings in 35 appearances. The Yankees scooped him up for nothing, and by mid-August he made the MLB roster for them. During his Yankees tenure, he posted fine pitching stats, but the sample size is quite small to gain any true data from, as is the case with many relief pitchers.


Mayza's case rests mostly on his 2021-2023 numbers, which includes a 2.67 ERA over 155 innings in 193 games with 154 strikeouts and a 158 ERA+. (In 2023 alone, he posted a 284 ERA+.) If the Yankees believe they can recapture that type of reliever, especially for a left-handed arm, that would be amazing. And, entering his age-32 season, that shouldn't be impossible. However, a $1.1 Million dollar raise after a season where he was DFA'ed and released? That seems like too much.


Would I Re-Sign Him? Only if the arbitration projections are off. Mayza is a medium-risk, medium-reward reliever. Even if his stuff doesn't return to his great form, he's serviceable. If it does return, he's amazing. But, I wouldn't take that as a salary of $4 Million. Instead, let's run it back at $3.5M. That seems fair.

 

Player Three: Nestor Cortes (LHSP)

2024 Stats: 31 GP (30 Starts), 9-10 Record, 3.77 ERA (109 ERA+), 174.1 IP, 162 K's, 39 BB's

2024 Salary: $3,950,000

2025 Arbitration Projection: $7,700,000


Nestor Cortes has been one of the most exciting starting pitchers to watch in baseball during the last few years. However this excitement has been taken from us a lot recently: his 2023 season ended with injury in August (after returning for a week from a June injury), and his 2024 season ended with injury.


However, I admire Cortes telling the Yankees he was willing to do whatever the team needed- including hurting himself for all of 2025- in the World Series. That type of grit and determination is the mark of a true team player. Unfortunately, Aaron Boone used him incorrectly in Game 1 of the World Series, and that moment will serve as a blemish against Cortes. However, his stats are still good to very good.


He'll be 30 years old in 2025 and set to enter free agency after this season. Some predictors expect him to easily top $8 Million.


Would I Re-Sign Him? Yes. Good starting pitching is hard to come by for the Yankees, and Nestor has done a good-to-great job as a 4th or 5th starter for them. Let me continue to be a little stingy and try to lower his salary down to $7.5 Million for 2025 (any little bit saved can be added to the Soto coffer), but this is an easy decision.

 

Player Four: Jose Trevino (C)

2024 Stats: 73 GP, .215/.288/.354/.642, 81 OPS+, 45 H, 8 HR, 28 RBI's, +0.6 bWAR

2024 Salary: $2,730,000

2025 Arbitration Projection: $3,400,000


Jose Trevino is still a glove-first catcher with a good ability to frame pitches. However, this skill alone does not mean he should stay with the Yankees for 2025. He is comfortably below-average as a hitter, and this past season showed a massive flaw, that many teams took comfortable advantage of: he cannot throw runners out on the bases.


The problem here for the Yankees is that Austin Wells (who will be their starting catcher) showed that he cannot hit left-handed pitchers. They will need a good back-up catcher who can hit lefties. There are tons of older catchers available on the free agent market: Danny Jansen, Yasmani Grandal, Travis d'Arnaud, Carson Kelly, and Gary Sanchez stand out as somewhat notable right-handed names. The question is how lucrative the market will be.


And, a special shout-out to my favorite former Yankee, Kyle Higashioka, who is expected to sign a 2/$15M contract this offseason. (I'm so happy for him! But, also a little sad because that price-tag is going to keep him away from a return to the Yankees.)


Would I Re-Sign Him? No. I am not confident in Jose Trevino's abilities anymore, and quite simply, I would not field a team with a back-up catcher who can't throw and can't hit. Somebody will want him as a low-value trade piece. But, I'm comfortable finding another option on the free agent market.

 

Player Five: Trent Grisham (OF)

2024 Stats: 76 GP, .190/.290/.385/.675, 90 OPS+, 34 H, 9 HR, 31 RBI's, +0.4 bWAR

2024 Salary: $5,500,000

2025 Arbitration Projection: $5,700,000


Trent Grisham was acquired as part of the massive trade that sent Juan Soto to the Yankees from the Padres, who acquired a slew of starting pitchers (and Kyle Higashioka). He was expected to be the Yankees center fielder for the 2024 season, and instead he became a 4th outfielder for them as Aaron Judge took over center field duties, Juan Soto took over in right, and Alex Verdugo took over in left.


With the Yankees set to lose Verdugo in free agency, there looks to be an open spot for Grisham...if not for Jasson Dominguez being ready (hopefully) to set the league on fire.


For the last 3 seasons, Trent Grisham has posted a batting average below the Mendoza line. That's where any conversation of his returning should end. All of his value is held up in his glove, and that is not a valuable enough tool for a bench role.


Would I Re-Sign Him? No. What's best for Grisham is for the Yankees to find a place where he can become an everyday center fielder again. He should be traded to a team that does not have World Series aspirations, so that he can play everyday and regain value ahead of his free agency next year. He's not a bench or a role player. He's a glove first outfielder, and that is only valuable if he's in the field. The Yankees are not the team for him in 2025.

5 Comments


fuster
Nov 09

Grisham was paid $5.5M last season and is expected to get a very modest salary increase for next season.

Verdugo was paid $8.7M last season and will not be retained.

he will be replaced by Jasson Dominguez who will be paid less than $1M


Grisham is the best outfield defender on the roster

and the roster, as currently constructed, contains three outfielders

Soto is the hoped-for addition


might be best not to turn up our noses at the offensively-deficient Mr Grisham.

Like

Alan B.
Alan B.
Nov 09

Mayza: non-tender

Cortes: tender

Berti: tender

Trevino and Grisham: I'm still on the fence. If Brandon Lockridge was still here, no question with Grisham, Someone still needs to explain the purpose of that trade. Trevino. Are they ready to sign a vet for more money then justify that contract by playing Wells less? Or is Narvaéz a legit option as far as they are concerned to backup Wells? If I had to make the decision today, I'd tender Trevino, and non-tender Grisham, and go find myself an all 3 OF spots speedy defensive OF.

Edited
Like

yankeesblog
Nov 09

Berti: No, He's a 35-year old guy who's value is mostly tied up in this legs and who had two significant injuries to his legs last season and has not posted an OPS+ >= 100 since 2020. Mayza: No. He's a low-leverage guy. Should be easy to replace for less money. Cortes: Yes unless he needs surgery. In the latter case he will miss next season which is his walk year.

Trevino: No. I don't give a rip about framing and the rest of his defense has evaporated. Sign one of the guys you mentioned. Grisham: No. He's poetry in motion in the OF but the perfect illustration of a guy who couldn't hit water if he fell out of a boat. The…

Edited
Like

mikemarinelli54
Nov 09

Slightly off topic, but just announced that Roki Sasaki WILL be posted.

You hear that Hal and Brian?

Edited
Like
yankeesblog
Nov 09
Replying to

Yes the Yankees need to be all over this.

Like
dr sem.png

Start Spreading the News is the place for some of the very best analysis and insight focusing primarily on the New York Yankees.

(Please note that we are not affiliated with the Yankees and that the news, perspectives, and ideas are entirely our own.)

blog+image+2.jpeg

Have a question for the Weekly Mailbag?

Click below or e-mail:

SSTNReaderMail@gmail.com

SSTN is proudly affiliated with Wilson Sporting Goods! Check out our press release here, and support us by using the affiliate links below:

587611.jpg
583250.jpg
Scattering the Ashes.jpeg

"Scattering The Ashes has all the feels. Paul Russell Semendinger's debut novel taps into every emotion. You'll laugh. You'll cry. You'll reexamine those relationships that give your life meaning." — Don Burke, writer at The New York Post

The Least Among Them.png

"This charming and meticulously researched book will remind you of baseball’s power to change and enrich lives far beyond the diamond."

—Jonathan Eig, New York Times best-selling author of Luckiest Man, Opening Day, and Ali: A Life

From Compton to the Bronx.jpg

"A young man from Compton rises to the highest levels of baseball greatness.

Considered one of the classiest baseball players ever, this is Roy White's story, but it's also the story of a unique period in baseball history when the Yankees fell from grace and regained glory and the country dealt with societal changes in many ways."

foco-yankees.png

We are excited to announce our new sponsorship with FOCO for all officially licensed goods!

FOCO Featured:
carlos rodon bobblehead foco.jpg
bottom of page