Rule 5 Primer
by James Vlietstra
November 17, 2026
***
The World Series is over. The deadline for adding prospects that are Rule 5 eligible to the roster is November 18. Typically, I would be very excited and stating cases for why certain players should be added. However, with the labor agreement set to expire on December 1st, the R5 draft will probably not even happen this offseason. There's much more pressing issues and unfortunately, to the detriment of the sport, I don't see a quick end to the dispute. But here at SSTN, we cover baseball...
So, on this rainy afternoon, I am going to list a bunch of players that are eligible to be taken in the draft, if not added to the list already. With all the recent players that declared free agency, the Yankees' current 40- man roster sits at 33 players. That is with the recent addition of Marco Luciano, who would have been able to leave as a minor league free agent if they didn't add him.
There's currently eight players on the MLB Pipeline top 30. There's another dozen or so players that were once very highly regarded prospects. Of these 20 players, they will probably only add about 3-4. Last year, I was confident they were going to add closer to 7-8 and was disappointed with the final list. I was sure that they were going to be plundered during the draft. I was wrong.
The front office obviously knows their players better than I. This year with a high likelihood of there not even being a draft, they will probably only add 2.
First, a quick introduction to Marco Luciano. He's a 24 year old 2B that had a .933 OPS between AA and AAA, He has Major League experience from his time in San Francisco.
Carlos LaGrange (MLB Pipeline #3) made it to AAA as a RHP starter throwing 103 and they shifted him to the bullpen with the intention of him contributing towards any deep postseason they were to have in 2026. Unfortunately, he was injured and that didn't happen. Unlike some players that are placed on the 40 while in A ball and remain in the minors until they are out of options, LaGrange could contribute next year. He will definitely be added.
Allen Facundo (#7) Also 23, he has dealt with lots of injuries and has not pitched above A+ yet. He's a hard throwing LHP. If it was a normal year, they probably would add him. I doubt they will this year.
Kyle Carr (#12) He is 24 and had a hot streak in Somerset which earned him a promotion to AAA. He is a RHP starter that is just about ready for the Majors. He could be selected which would be a reason to protect him. He's probably a 50/50, possibly just slightly favoring add, so I'll say add.
Luis Serna (#18) As a 21 year old in A+, he threw 118 innings with a K/BB ratio of 3.5. The RHP could very likely be in AA and a top trade chip in July, but I don't see them protecting him.
Cade Smith (#21) The 24 year old RHP threw 124 innings in AA. I don't see them protecting him, but he could stick if selected by another team.
Jace Avina (#24) The 23 year old OF had a very good season in AA, producing an OPS of 0.817. Not the type of player that would typically taken and stashed on a roster when most teams only carry 3-4 bench players.
Omar Alfonzo (#28) The 22 year old Catcher struggled at AA, putting up a .363 OPS. Definitely will not be protected.
Coby Morales (#29) The 24 year old 3B had an OPS of .850 in AA. He could comptete for a roster spot in spring training, but it's unlikely he will be added, especially if there's a chance that they cancel the draft.
Roderick Arias Once was a top prospect, but his luster fell off. He returned this season as a 21 year old in AA and excelled. He plays 3B/SS/2B and has the pedigree of a top prospect. He probably would be selected in a draft. I think there's a very good chance that he is protected.
Brock Selvidge started last spring training as a former top prospect and was on top of his game. Until an injury cut his season down before it started. He should be back by midseason, but unlikely to be selected.
I am going to name a bunch of other players that I don't believe will be protected or selected.
Sabier Marte
Sean Paul Linan
Thomas Balboni
Bryce Warrecker
Antonio Gomez
Enmanuel Tejada
Tyler Hardman
And here are a bunch of older relief pitchers that were all in AAA last year. Unlikely to be protected, but could possibly be selected to another team and given an opportunity.
Eric Reyzelman
Carson Coleman
Zach Messinger
Harrison Cohen
Danny Watson.
My prediction is that LaGrange and Arias will be protected and possibly Carr.
What do you think? I would love to get your feedback.














Comments