Should Spencer Jones Play Center Field Next Year?
By EJ Fagan
November 2026
***
The following post comes from EJ Fagan's Substack, Baseball Is Life. It is shared with permission.
***
With Trent Grisham gone, Spencer Jones is the favorite to start the 2027 season in center field. His debut was a bit of a mixed bag:

Let’s start with hitting. As expected, Jones can hit the ball hard and far when he makes contact. His rates improve a lot after his July call up:
.262/.316/.526 expected batting line
34.5% strikeout rate
.358 xwOBA
His season makes a lot more sense in time series form:

He started the season hitting well but with an unsustainable 40%+ strikeout rate. After his final call up (game 31), he drove his strikeout rate all the way down to the 25-30% range, but pitchers adjusted and it eventually climbed to the mid-30s. Regardless, he hit like an MVP for the next month and a half before slumping in the final two weeks of the season.
He also had crazy left/right splits: a 1.107 OPS against lefties and .647 OPS against righties. Maybe he’ll be a reverse splits guy, but not to such an absurd degree.
Then there is defense. Spencer Jones is undeniably fast, although his Statcast metrics suggest that his overall range is below average due to relatively slow acceleration (his routes are average). He graded out as average in right field and well below average in center. DRS pretty much agrees perfectly.
So should the Yankees bet on Spencer Jones, rather than going out and acquiring a more traditional centerfielder?
I’m real hesitant. Spencer Jones could continue to progress from his rookie season (and 2025 breakout at Triple-A). Jones has the physical tools to be an absolute monster at the plate. A lot of hitters are succeeding right now with strike rates in the 30s - Munetaki Murakami (35%), Oneil Cruz (33%), Nick Kurtz (32%), Kyle Schwarber (31%) and Kyle Stowers (31%) are all coming off strong years. Even if he just matched his post-callup .358 xwOBA, he would be a top-30 hitter in baseball.
On the other hand, just as many qualified 2026 hitters over 30% were downright bad. There’s serious survivorship bias in that analysis. Striking out a ton is bad for very obvious reasons.
Could Spencer Jones follow Aaron Judge and lower his strikeout rate significantly? Judge was around 31% for his first three MLB seasons but in the 25-28% range since. While Judge is a bit of a unicorn, guys like James Wood and Elly De La Cruz have followed a similar path. I think Jones could be a monster with even a 30% strikeout rate.
But we also have to ask if he could regress the other way. After a great summer, Jones’ strikeout rate crept up into danger territory in September. He could be unplayable.
I think there is also a hidden discussion here about walks. Jones walked in just 8% of plate appearances in 2026. That’s way too low for a high strikeout rate. The other successful high strikeout rate guys walk a ton - 15% for Murakami and Schwarber, 16% for Wood, 11% for Cruz and Stowers. Judge was even higher when he was striking out a lot. Jones was a little better in the minors, so maybe can start getting on base a little more.
And of course, we need to talk about defense. Jones has the top speed to play center and takes pretty strong routes, but his reaction time and acceleration hold him back. I think he’s safe as a playable centerfielder, but really should be in a corner.
This all adds up to a lot of uncertainty. The Yankees could have their centerfielder for the foreseeable future. Or they could end up scrambling at the trade deadline. I think they probably have bigger problems to worry about, but I’m nervous about relying on Jones.
I think they probably hedge their bets by acquiring a strong backup centerfielder. Daulton Varsho might take a bench role after a weak year. Maybe someone like Lane Tomas, Cedric Mullins or TJ Friedl. I’ll take a glove first guy with bounceback potential.














Jones will be given every opportunity to be the CF this year. If he adjusts and reduces his strikeouts the Yankees will be OK with him in the lineup. Jones like most young players needs to play so obsessing on last year stats is nice winter conservations but play him and worry more about 3B, and keeping our pitching staff healthy!
You talk about how Judge lowered his strike out rate. But how many times did we see him “strike out” on ballls that were low and not close to being a strike. That’s not his fault. But it counts in his strike out rate. Umpires were getting a little better at realizing his strike zone. But the ABS system surely helped too this year. Jones had all his strike outs when the ABS system was being used. Big difference from Judge’s strike out rate earlier in his career. Jones “earned” his strike outs. Judge got screwed quite often. 🤷♂️
He should be given chance to earn the spot. Part of that opportunity should be cutting back his swing and k rate. He doesn't need a 270+ degree upper cut swing --with all that xtra re setting movement. The power, its already there. They wont put that contingency on it, though. He'll K 33+ % using that swing.
I think the more MLB games Jones has in center, the better he'll get. I'm very much in favor of seeing what he can do as the started. But I also agree that having a glove-first guy on the bench who can back up all three positions would be a very good thing to have.