Shredder vs Determinator: Catchers

With the 2022 season looming, let’s take a look to see how my The Determinator ranks up against MLB Network’s The Shredder.

Today we start this quick mini recap series with Catchers.

---

The Shredder vs. The Determinator:

The Shredder, from MLB Network’s Top 10: Catchers

The Determinator, from SSTN’s Top 10: Catchers

---

Key Notes of Difference:

1. 
   

The Shredder and The Determinator differed on including 3 different players for each list:

1. 
   

The Shredder:

1. 
   

Buster Posey (SFG/Retired)

1. 
   

Max Stassi (LAA)

1. 
   

Omar Narvaez (MIL)

1. 
   

The Determinator:

1. 
   

Mitch Garver (TEX)

1. 
   

Jacob Stallings (MIA)

1. 
   

Carson Kelly (ARZ)

1. 
   

The Shredder to The Determinator agreed on 6 different players in the Top-10, however we did see them ranked differently (the first number is where they ranked on The Shredder and second number is where they ranked via The Determinator):

1. 
   

Yasmani Grandal (#2 -> #8)

1. 
   

Will Smith (#3 -> #2)

1. 
   

Willson Contreras (#4 -> #10)

1. 
   

Salvador Perez (#5 -> #4)

1. 
   

Sean Murphy (#7 -> #9)

1. 
   

Mike Zunino (#9 -> #5)

1. 
   

However, we don’t always disagree! We had 1 player that was unanimously placed between both The Shredder and The Determinator:

1. 
   

J.T. Realmuto (#1)

1. 
   

Click here to see each installment of The Determinator:

1. 
   

#10 – 6 Catchers

1. 
   

#5 – 1 Catchers

1. 
   

Yankees, Honorable Mentions, and Statistic Leaders

#TheDeterminator