Who Would You Trade Spencer Jones For?
By EJ Fagan
November 2026
***
The following post comes from EJ Fagan's Substack, Baseball Is Life. It is shared with permission.
***
According to Brian Cashman, via Brendan Kuty, the Yankees are getting a lot of interest in Spencer Jones.
That’s real interesting news to me. As we talked about on the podcast this weekend, I’m pretty nervous about counting on Jones as a starting centerfielder to begin next season. He’s probably best suited for a corner. He’s risky. But he’s all they have right now.
Jones is also a really interesting trade piece. He’s good and ready to plug right into a major league lineup, but not so good that the Yankees would need to get a king’s ransom in return.
Who might be interested in Jones? I’ve got a few candidates. We’ll mostly ignore the “who plays center?” follow up question for now.
To the Cubs for Matt Shaw
This move feels obvious, with a caveat that I’ll get to later. The Cubs need outfielders. They have Alex Bregman at third and two young third basemen.
The more I stare at them, the more I think Matt Shaw and Spencer Jones are a great 1:1 trade. Shaw is a former top prospect. He’s 25 years old. He’s under team control through 2031 (one year fewer than Jones). He had a .737 OPS, although the Statcast page is uglier:

Shaw is athletic, right-handed and has a high contact swing. He’s definitely underperformed in the majors, but has also not had a regular spot in the lineup thanks to Alex Bregman.
The Yankees would be buying low on a much higher ranked prospect than Jones, while the Cubs would be buying high-ish on a low ranked prospect who seems closer to realizing his potential than ever. My only real knock on the trade is that the Cubs need a ton of pitching, so they might prefer a Will Warren or Ryan Weathers over Jones.
One wrinkle: Shaw started playing right field in 2026 and the Cubs might consider keeping him there permanently given his speed.
To the Pirates for Oneil Cruz
Oneil Cruz has two more years of team control left. He’s got a lot of Spencer Jones in him, both in terms of size, power and swing and miss. After years of struggle, he is coming off a very strong year:

That sure looks like a Yankees Statcast page, doesn’t it?
The upside for the Yankees is that Cruz can play a real centerfield. The Pirates would be selling high on him.
To the Rangers for Josh Jung
Another guy with two years of control left. The Rangers seem to heading toward a rebuild. The Yankees need a third baseman. Jung is coming off a strong season after two down years:

Jung fits the Yankees real well. He’s a right handed contact bat. He has strong splits against lefties but is still very playable against righties. The defense isn’t great, but it’s good enough for the time being.
The Rangers are a little short in left field and DH right now, and may even trade Wyatt Langford soon if they plan to go full rebuild.
To the Athletics (with Austin Wells) for Shea Langeliers
Langeliers was rumored to be on the block at the deadline before suffering a season ending injury. He’s a free agent in two years, so absent an extension is not a part of the Las Vegas future.
Langeliers has been one of the best all around catchers in baseball over the last two years:

I don’t think Jones gets it done on his own, so I’ve thrown in Austin Wells to the trade.
The A’s have a bit of a mess of a roster right now, with big extension guys like Jacob Wilson and Lawrence Butler having brutal 2026 seasons. It’s hard to tell if they would be interested in Jones over Butler. Or maybe the Yankees take a contract in return.
Some Quick Hits
I’m out of writing time, so a few others that I considered but ultimately rejected:
To the Nationals for CJ Abrams
To the Angels for Zach Neto
To the Marlins for Xavier Edwards
To the Rockies for Hunter Goodman
To the Twins for Brooks Lee














To the A's for Zack Gelof.
I'm sticking with my woolly WAG about trading for Wyatt Langford.
Spencer Jones and Heliot Ramos and Will Warren ......... and Elmer Rodriguez or Ben Hess
including accepting Seager and all of the $150m+ still owed to him
taking Seager and eating the salary alleviates a major problem for Texas, opening a spot for Walcott
having Warren on hand makes trading deGrom and Eovaldi far less fraught, especially if Texas trades one of the two in the off-season and holds the other until the in-season deadline