top of page
  • Cary Greene

Last Offseason I Said…

by Cary Greene

November 13, 2022


It’s true, last offseason, I said the Yankees needed to sign better relievers. I wasn’t convinced that either Aroldis Chapman or Zack Britton would be of much help. Instead, Cashman did “nada” to improve the Yankees bullpen.

I also said last winter that Cashman should sign the highly-affordable David Robertson to bolster the Yankees high-leverage relief corps!

It’s also true that I said the Yankees should have signed a legit lefty-starter like Carlos Rodon and also pulled an offseason blockbuster trade off with the prospect starved Reds for Luis Castillo. Instead Cashman did nothing to improve the Yankees rotation. Again…he did “nada.”

Then Cashman compounded his inability to build a World Series capable rotation by trading away valuable prospects at yet another deadline, but for the likes of Frankie Montas?!

I won’t deny, I also said the Yankees should sign Kyle Schwarber and play Giancarlo Stanton a lot more in the outfield, in order to find a way to get a dead-red pull hitter between Stanton and Aaron Judge. I said the move would pay huge dividends in the playoffs. (Did anybody happen to see Schwarber with the Phillies in this year’s postseason? Remember “Schwaba’s” 119.7 mph, 488’ bomb against the Padres this year, which was the hardest-hit ball in the modern, StatCast postseason era?)

..the guy is nothing short of the kind of bat a GM should want on a World Series team.

Non-baseball guys like Cashman or Yankees Analytics boss Michael Fishman for whatever reason just can’t put together a lineup that can score in the postseason. They just don’t really understand how to get the job done and all they do is keep proving this to Yankees fans everywhere.

The Yankees also try to dictate their plan in big games, then they lean on an inexperienced PR-man like Aaron Boone, and expect him to do what? Lead the team on the field in the biggest of moments? This way of operating tends to backfire when it matters most. It’s just not a recipe for winning a championship.

I mean, we go through this every offseason don’t we? What should be so easy is made so hard by people who really don’t know baseball as well as they purport to. It would be neat if Cashman and Fishman would take a few steps back and let the kinds of decisions be made that might even result in a ticker-tape parade.

Good decisions sometimes are evidenced quickly, but at other times, they may take some time to come together and be apparent.

I ask this question. Would any of us have known that the real problem with the Phillies this season was actually Joe Girardi and the way he was leaning on unproductive veterans and refusing to give younger, but highly “mature for their age” players a shot?

Sometimes, leadership has a way of shooting a team in the foot. How many times have we seen a team make a change at the right time in the season, with plenty of time left, and suddenly the team catches fire and they go on a tear?

We fans? Those of us who are experienced enough to know what works and what doesn’t - what about us? Sometimes we see things very easily and very clearly. We’re also not always right, and I get that. In fact, it’s why I said Cashman and Fishman should simply consider taking a step back. All the data, all the analytics, it’s great, but it’s often just data in a vacuum.

Tom Coughlan said, “Preparation is the key to success” and I love that quote. Process is important. So why isn’t Cashman looking at Boone’s “process” in the postseason? In fact, why isn’t Cashman using a better “process” to construct his rosters? The right field fence is set at 314-feet, why not either move it back 200-feet or sign a few guys on both sides of the ball that can exploit this wonder of nature?

The key is to give that data to real baseball people and let them do something with it during games. Make it available to them, but please, step back. Stop pre-planning and pre-scripting everything. Stop making your on-the-field manager stay within whatever the game plan is every day. Especially in the playoffs! Stop picking bad playoffs rosters. Stop signing or trading for players with significant injury concerns. Stop being so right-handed in the lineup, the bullpen and rotation.

Start building the team the right way. Do it THIS OFFSEASON. Start with the lineup and the rotation. Championship architecture isn’t an exact science. There are certain pieces, be it leadership or personnel, that need to come together in order to eventually create magic. Usually, a team’s pitching has to really heat up or peak and they also have to hit against the very good pitching they’ll absolutely face as they advance.

If a GM can’t craft a roster that can deliver a championship after 13-years in a row, maybe he should just….take a step back. Brian Cashman didn’t win his championships with rosters he created. Gene Michael should get the credit for all those banners and parades. What has Cashman done? Create a process he believes is great but that also fails to deliver? Am I supposed to buy that?

Yet here we are. I hate to say I told you so Brian Cashman. But I did. A whole year in advance. In fact, many of us here on SSTN said so, writers and posters alike and now we’re going to watch Hal Steinbrenner bring Cashman back because the “process” was great! Hall is about to rinse and repeat.

No significant changes will be made. We’ll roll out the same leadership. We’ll do things the same way we always do. Michael Fishman will effectively run the team. He’ll make the plan Boone follows and stays within. It’ll be a really good plan that helps the Yankees win enough games against a majority of light-spending regular season opponents and the Yankees may make the playoffs yet again. What’s so great about that?

What’s so great about beating up on a bunch of light-spending teams and then getting eliminated every year in the postseason, when the competition gets better?

Something, my friends, is wrong with the Yankees process.

9 commentaires

14 nov. 2022

I'm happy to see that I'm not crazy when I say that both Cashman and Boone need to have their boarding passes scanned for their permanent flight out of town. What is most impressive but at the same time depressing is that the people that write for and follow SSTN know more about how to run a ball club than the two jokers currently in the jobs. It's true: left-handed pitching and a left handed dominant lineup is what wins at the Stadium. Always has, always will. Just as an aside, the Red Sox at Fenway load up on right handed pitching and right handed hitters for obvious reasons. Most smart organizations play to their ballpark unless their places …


Cary Greene
Cary Greene
14 nov. 2022

Let's comprimse. 110' then! But seriously, if the only lefty starter you have is Nestor Cortes, who generates tons of medium-hard contact that gets hit to left field and center field, why not move it back 200' and force opponents to go with right-handed hitters against all the right-handed pitchers.


13 nov. 2022

Look back through the championship years. Yankee Stadium the old one and the the new one favors lefty starters and left handed sticks. From Eddie Lopat, Ron Guidry, Whitey Ford. Andy P. to the bats …like Charlie Keller, Tommy Heinrich, Johnny Blanchard,Roger Maris,Graig Nettles,Yogi…etc. …use what the park gives you!

Cary Greene
Cary Greene
14 nov. 2022
En réponse à

There are too many blunders to support any notion that the process is good. It may seem good to Cashman and Steinbrenner, but what does either of them know about doing what it takes to win World Series titles. Hal has a winning percentage as a GM that's actually a smidge higher than what his father's was. Yet, his father runs rings around him in terms of winning when it matters most. Hal's very good at beating have-nots, but, when the competition gets better - his Yankees teams wilt. That's the narrative Hal is busily writing. That's his legacy.


13 nov. 2022

true about Chapman and Britton, but

Holmes, King, Green, Peralta, & Marinaccio

were pretty good

Cary Greene
Cary Greene
14 nov. 2022
En réponse à

Yea but Kiner Falefa, Donaldson, Gallo, Hicks, Stanton and Montas were all pretty bad.

Cashman can take credit for trading for Mike King but wasn't Marinaccio drafted by Oppenheimer in the 19-round in 2017?

Trevino and Carpenter were nice finds, but look at all the talent Cashman has squandered away - much of it could have helped substantially. Whitlock, Stephan, Feyereisen, Estrada, Mateo, Duran, Smith..etc.

Also, the Yankees failed to get past Houston this year and Cashman failed to build a team capable of doing that.


13 nov. 2022

I think you mean move the RF fence back 20 feet not 200 feet😀

dr sem.png

Start Spreading the News is the place for some of the very best analysis and insight focusing primarily on the New York Yankees.

(Please note that we are not affiliated with the Yankees and that the news, perspectives, and ideas are entirely our own.)


Have a question for the Weekly Mailbag?

Click below or e-mail:

SSTN is proudly affiliated with Wilson Sporting Goods! Check out our press release here, and support us by using the affiliate links below:

Scattering the Ashes.jpeg

"Scattering The Ashes has all the feels. Paul Russell Semendinger's debut novel taps into every emotion. You'll laugh. You'll cry. You'll reexamine those relationships that give your life meaning." — Don Burke, writer at The New York Post

The Least Among Them.png

"This charming and meticulously researched book will remind you of baseball’s power to change and enrich lives far beyond the diamond."

—Jonathan Eig, New York Times best-selling author of Luckiest Man, Opening Day, and Ali: A Life

From Compton to the Bronx.jpg

"A young man from Compton rises to the highest levels of baseball greatness.

Considered one of the classiest baseball players ever, this is Roy White's story, but it's also the story of a unique period in baseball history when the Yankees fell from grace and regained glory and the country dealt with societal changes in many ways."


We are excited to announce our new sponsorship with FOCO for all officially licensed goods!

FOCO Featured:
carlos rodon bobblehead foco.jpg
bottom of page