COUNTING DOWN: The Best Yankee At Each Uniform Number (#7)
- Paul Semendinger
- Mar 23, 2023
- 5 min read
By Paul Semendinger
***
Mickey Mantle was the greatest Yankee to wear uniform #7. Of course.
Mickey Mantle was arguably the third greatest Yankee of All-Time. Only three Yankees earned over 100 career WAR in pinstripes:
Babe Ruth 143.4
Lou Gehrig 113.6
Mickey Mantle 110.2
After Mantle, it's not really close. Ruth, Gehrig, and Mantle are light years ahead of the other legendary Yankees:
Joe DiMaggio 79.2
Derek Jeter 71.3
Yogi Berra 59.6
Bill Dickey 56.4
Willie Randolph 54.1
Alex Rodriguez 54.0
Bernie Williams 49.6
Mickey Mantle was that good. Mickey Mantle was that great.
But, Mickey Mantle was even greater than one might imagine. A good argument can be made that Mickey Mantle was one of the greatest players to ever play the game.
Many people consider Willie Mays the greatest baseball player of all-time. He might have been. The purpose of this article isn't to debate that point, but one can point to some stats that demonstrate that at his best, Mantle was every bit as good as Mays. And, maybe even better...
Willie Mays' best single season by OPS+ was 1965. He won the MVP that year as he batted .317/52/112. Mays' OPS+ in 1965 was 185.
Mickey Mantle had five full seasons (FIVE!) with an OPS+ above 185:
1957 OPS+ 221 .365/34/94
1956 OPS+ 210 .353/52/130
1961 OPS+ 206 .317/54/128
1962 OPS+ 195 .321/30/89
1958 OPS+ 188 .304/42/97
That's a powerful statement. Mickey Mantle had five seasons with an OPS+ better than Willie Mays' best season by that measurement.
And there is more:
Willie Mays' best OPS in a season was 1.078. Mickey Mantle's was 1.177
Willie Mays had five seasons with an OPS above 1.000. Mickey Mantle had eight.
Willie Mays' best slugging percentage was .667. Mickey Mantle's was .705.
Let's look at their career numbers in OPB/SLG/OPS:
MAYS .384/.557/.940
MANTLE .421/.557/.977
These are pretty straightforward numbers and they show that Mantle was an offensive powerhouse just as good as Mays. And, again, an argument can be made that Mantle was better.
But... there's more:
Willie Mays played in five World Series. His team won once.
Mickey Mantle played in twelve World Series. His team won seven times.
***
Now, to be fair, lifetime WAR tells a story that is much more favorable to Willie Mays. In this area, Mays crushes Mantle (156.1 to 110.2). If WAR is the statistic that ends all arguments, the case is settled. Willie Mays was a better player. Still, I don't think many fans today realize how truly great Mickey Mantle was.
There aren't many players that can hang with Willie Mays. Mickey Mantle does.
In short, Mickey Mantle wasn't just the greatest Yankee to wear uniform number 7, Mickey Mantle was one of the greatest players to ever play the game.
***
Most of the background research for this project came from Baseball-Reference.com and the SABR BioProject.
***
PREVIOUS ARTICLES IN THIS SERIES: (All the links should work. If not, please let us know.)
