PINSTRIPE PINWHEEL: Recent Roster Moves & Reactions
by John Nielsen
November 20, 2026
***
Nov 17 – RP David Bednar Agreed to a 1-year contract (2027)
The Yankees received some extremely good news Tuesday with the return of closer David Bednar, who accepted the $23.15 million Qualifying Offer. In doing so, he was one of only two MLB players to do so, this cycle – the other was MIN catcher Ryan Jeffers. Bednar’s decision ensures that the ninth inning is in good hands for 2027 and puts a giant checkmark next to the first item on Brian Cashman’s offseason “To-Do List.”
“El Oso” (“The Bear”), a two-time All-Star and the pride of Lafayette College in Easton, PA, delivered 1.9 WAR in 2026, posting a 2.47 ERA (2.61 FIP) and a 1.04 WHIP over 69.1 innings. He struck out 76 and issued just 18 unintentional walks, while allowing only one home run about every 15 innings. He finished 7-3, converting 35 of 39 save opportunities, and added three scoreless innings in the postseason. Along the way, he earned Aaron Boone’s trust as the man to close things out.
There’s plenty to like under the hood, too, according to Baseball Savant’s Statcast metrics. Bednar ranked at or above the 70th percentile in every category. He posted one of MLB’s highest Chase Rates, did an excellent job limiting both Exit Velocity and Barrel Rates, and generated a healthy number of ground balls. In short, the underlying numbers reinforce what his results already showed: Bednar was one of the Yankees’ most dependable and lethal weapons in 2026.

Bednar’s four-seam fastball and splitter combination is elite, and in 2026 he was even more effective against left-handed hitters than those swinging from the starboard side.
This is an excellent retention that exquisitely solidifies the back end of the Yankees’ bullpen. While the price is steep, the Yankees are committing to just one year as Bednar enters his age-32 season. In 2028, they’ll have the option of extending him on a multi-year deal or moving on to the next era of Yankee closers.
GRADE: GOLD – Pure gold!
Nov 15 – RP Tim Hill Agreed to a 1-year contract (2027) with Club Option
In contrast to the well-conceived Bednar signing, bringing back Tim Hill for another year, with a club option for 2028, is a real head-scratcher. In my opinion, this is an unforced error – a waste of money and a roster spot.
“Tim Jim” got off to a strong start in 2026, posting a 1.42 ERA over 12.2 innings during March and April. He allowed just one home run and issued only two walks over that stretch. Unfortunately, it was sharply downhill from there. From May 1 through the end of the season, Hill was dismal, recording a 6.07 ERA. He was particularly ineffective in September, when he posted a 9.53 ERA. His FIP tells an even less flattering story: 5.93, the highest of his career.
For the season, Hill produced a 4.60 ERA and 0.0 WAR. While his 1.14 WHIP was respectable, allowing a home run roughly every five innings was not. He also blew all four of his save opportunities, although he did pick up five wins against two losses in relief.
And just look at the Statcast data:

Hill is well known as a soft tosser, with his fastball averaging just 88 mph, placing him in the lowest percentile in MLB. His calling card is generating ground balls with his sinker, which he throws approximately 85% of the time. That approach did produce MLB’s best Ground Ball Rate at 68.9%. His control was also excellent, as reflected in his 93rd-percentile Walk Rate.
The problem, however, was that Hill was hit hard (12th-percentile Hard-Hit Rate) and surrendered far too many home runs in 2026. His HR/9 rate ballooned to 1.84, compared with a much more manageable 1.07 in 2025 and an outstanding 0.41 over 44 innings with the Yankees in 2024. His effectiveness also diminished as the season wore on.
I'm honestly at a loss to explain why the Yankees brought him back, other than the fact that he was fairly inexpensive: $2.25 million for 2027, with a club option at the same price for 2028, when Hill will be entering his age-38 season. But is even that a bargain? Wouldn't the Yankees be better off saving the money (and the additional luxury-tax hit) and simply paying the league minimum to someone else?
To make matters worse, Hill now occupies a roster spot that could be put to much better use. Why not clear an extra spot for 24-year-old left-handed flamethrower Allen Facundo (more on him, later), give him a chance at the league minimum, and protect him from the Rule 5 Draft? Or take a flyer on a much younger free-agent left-handed reliever as a reclamation project on a MLB contract (or even an NRI): 30-year-old Caleb Ferguson (just a year removed from a 3.58 ERA over 65.1 innings in 2025), 33-year-old Jalen Beeks (who posted a 3.81 ERA over 26 innings in 2026), or 29-year-old Kolby Allard (coming off a 2.63 ERA over 65 innings in 2025). Take your pick. Any of those options would seem to offer more upside, at the same or less money, than bringing back Hill.
Doesn't this signing simply block the next Brent Headrick from finding his way onto the Yankees' roster and into the bullpen? That's perhaps my biggest concern: the opportunity cost of giving a roster spot to an obvioiusly declining veteran rather than creating room for a younger arm with something to prove.
GRADE: NOT ON THE MEDAL STAND — Why, Cashman? Why? Seriously! Why?
Nov 17 – SP Chase Hampton Claimed Off Waivers from BAL
Speaking of reclamation projects, right-handed starter Chase Hampton is once again a New York Yankee.
Once a top Yankees prospect—and still ranked by Baseball America as the organization’s No. 10 prospect entering 2026—Hampton, much like Marco Luciano last winter, has been passed around more often than a hookah pipe in a Moroccan casbah in recent months.
Hampton took quite the circuitous route through four MLB organizations in just over two months before the Yankees brought him back, Tuesday. The Yankees originally designated him for assignment in September to make room for Aaron Judge’s return from the injured list. From there, Hampton went to Washington, then St. Louis, then Baltimore, before ultimately finding his way back to New York. In all, he was claimed off waivers four times in 66 days without throwing a single major-league pitch.
The Yankees essentially reacquired the 2022 sixth-round pick (Texas Tech) and once-promising pitching prospect without surrendering a player, draft pick or even cash. All he costs them is a roster spot and the MLB minimum salary in 2027. After missing all of 2025 while recovering from Tommy John surgery, Hampton struggled badly in 2026, going 0-6 with an 8.18 ERA over 17 starts and 55 innings across Low-A, High-A and Double-A. Still, reclaiming him gives the Yankees another opportunity to see whether he can regain his form.
As the 39th or 40th player on a 40-man roster, Hampton’s second stint in the organization could also be short-lived. A free-agent signing or a Rule 5 Draft acquisition—or two or three—could easily land Hampton back in DFA limbo.
GRADE: BRONZE — A markedly better move than re-signing Tim Hill.
Nov 17 – Selected the contract of SP/RP Carlos Lagrange from Triple-A The decision to add #3 Yankee prospect SP/RP Carlos Lagrange to the 40-man roster was as easy as taking a postseason series from an AL Central team. You do it ten times out of ten. Even with the shoulder injury and control concerns, the upside is enormous.
At the start of the season, the Yankees were determined to keep Lagrange stretched out as a starter. But as the calendar flipped to June, the transition to a relief role began in earnest. Things started out swimmingly. In his first six relief appearances, the 6-foot-6, 240-pound right-hander went 1-0 with a save, allowing just three earned runs over 13⅔ innings (1.98 ERA). He walked six and struck out 19. The walks were a bit high, but everything else looked good.
Then, on June 28, just four weeks into his new bullpen assignment, the Dominican struggled to get through two-thirds of an inning against the Indianapolis Indians. He surrendered four hits and two walks, giving up five runs, all earned, taking the loss. Worst of all, his shoulder gave out, and he was subsequently diagnosed with a capsular sprain and shut down indefinitely.
Although the injury cost Lagrange nearly three months of the 2026 season, his September return was encouraging. On September 16, in his lone appearance after coming off the injured list, he threw a scoreless inning and touched 102.1 mph. Brian Cashman recently declared the 23-year-old healthy and ready to go. That's encouraging news, but a shoulder capsular sprain is hardly something to dismiss in a young pitcher who touches 102 mph. The capsule is an important stabilizing structure in the throwing shoulder, and the real test will be whether Lagrange can tolerate the workload of a starting pitcher over an extended period.
For the season, Lagrange was limited to 64⅓ innings, all at Triple-A. Despite his tremendous raw talent, his 4.48 ERA was pedestrian at best and not far removed from his career 4.15 ERA in the minors. It's the 386 strikeouts in 280 minor-league innings that are truly eye-popping—a strong 12.4 K/9. The potential for greatness is clearly there. Unfortunately, so is the control problem, reflected in a career 5.1 BB/9 (4.6 in 2026).
The Yankees say they plan to return Lagrange to a starting role in 2027, where his considerable upside will be worth monitoring. However, given the riches the Yankees currently enjoy in their starting rotation, I believe the best contribution Lagrange can make—and perhaps the one that would best protect his arm over the long haul—is in the bullpen. He could become a power-armed bridge between Yankee starters and the back end of the bullpen, where David Bednar looms.
Imagine trying to navigate six innings against Schlittler, Fried, Cole or Rodón, only to face Lagrange, Headrick, Blackburn (or, if you want to dream, Morejón?) and Bednar over the final three. That's an imposing proposition for any opposing lineup, whether in the regular season or the World Series.
If Lagrange can handle the pressures of the Bronx and the demands of high-leverage situations, he could emerge as the Yankees' closer as soon as 2028.
GRADE: GOLD — This decision was as easy as a Jalen Brunson layup!
Nov 17 – Selected the contract of SP Kyle Carr from Triple-A
Left-handed starting pitcher Kyle Carr’s promotion to the 40-man roster was a bit unexpected. There were several candidates for the spot, including right-hander Cade Smith and left-hander Allen Facundo. Both were ultimately left off the roster and exposed to the Rule 5 Draft in favor of Carr.
The 6-foot-1, 185-pound Carr began the year at Double-A Somerset before earning a midseason promotion to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre. In 21 games (20 starts) between the two levels, he posted a 4.58 ERA (4.82 FIP) over 90⅓ innings, with a 25.8% strikeout rate (11.4 K/9), a 10.8% walk rate and a 54.1% ground-ball rate—the 18th-best mark among minor-league starting pitchers with over 90 IP. That’s a nice combination of swing-and-miss stuff, decent control and ground balls, precisely the mix the Yankees covet most.
Having reached Triple-A, Carr faced a greater risk of being selected in the Rule 5 Draft. Another major-league club might have been willing to take a calculated gamble on him rather than let a potentially useful left-handed starter remain in the Yankees’ deep well of pitching talent. To me, that largely explains why Carr was protected while another left-hander with considerably better stuff—and, I would argue, greater upside—Allen Facundo, was left off the 40-man roster. Facundo has considerably less experience, having reached only High-A at age 24. Fingers crossed he can survive the Rule 5 Draft for a second consecutive year.
GRADE: BRONZE — I’m OK with Carr, so long as Facundo isn’t lost in the process.
Nov 17 – Selected the contract of OF Garrett Martin from Triple-A
Protecting 26-year-old, right-handed hitting, outfielder Garrett Martin from the Rule 5 Draft by adding him to the 40-man roster was also unexpected, if not shocking. Many thought this roster spot might potentially go to either 22-year-old third baseman Roderick Arias or 23-year-old outfielder Jace Avina. Perhaps the Yankees were concerned that a second-division club might view Martin as an immediate potential fourth outfielder and concluded he was worth Rule 5 protection. Whatever the reasoning, Martin unquestionably enjoyed a breakthrough season in 2026 before succumbing to an unspecified foot injury.
Martin is an undrafted free agent success story. In 2023, he hit .333/.461/.709 with 15 home runs at Austin Peay, a mid-major program with a surprisingly strong history of producing professional talent—50 MLB draftees since 1972, to be exact. It's not Oklahoma, Texas or LSU, but Austin Peay is a legitimate college baseball program that consistently produces MLB talent.
Signed by the Yankees as a UFA in 2023, the 6-foot-3, 217-pound Martin struggled at High-A Hudson Valley in 2024, hitting .216/.326/.422 with 12 home runs. He scuffled again after moving up to Double-A Somerset in 2025, batting .222/.292/.389 with 14 home runs in 102 games.
But something clicked in 2026, at least until the foot injury brought his season to an abrupt end on June 28 (same game as Carlos Lagrange went down). In 71 games between Somerset and Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre, Martin hit .270/.337/.570, launching 24 home runs in 326 plate appearances for a .907 OPS. He also stole 18 bases in 22 attempts, adding another dimension to his game. Defensively, Martin started 34 games in rightfield, 20 in centerfield and 3 in leftfield. Equally effective against right-handed pitching (.904 OPS) and left-handed pitching (.917 OPS), Martin is an intriguing unknown—and one the Yankees apparently believe is worth keeping around for further evaluation.
GRADE: SILVER — Martin may have found something in 2026. He's worth a spot on the 40-man roster, if only to give the Yankees a chance to learn more about what he can become and make sure no one “snakes” him out of the organization.
The Yankee 40-Man Roster now looks like this, currently including 39-players:
C: Wells/Sanchez/Escarra (3)
IF: Rice/Garcia/Lombard Jr./Volpe/McMahon/Caballero/Luciano/Schuemann (8)
OF: Judge/Bellinger/Jones/Ramos/Dominguez/Martin (6)
DH: Stanton (1)
SP: Schlittler/Fried/Cole/Rodon/Weathers/Warren/Rodriguez/Gil/Beck/Carr/Hampton (11)
RP: Bednar/Headrick/Schmidt/LeGrange/De Los Santos/Hill/Castro/Chivilli//Hanner/Cruz (10)
First three (or four) players off the Roster via non-tender: Cruz/Sanchez/Gil (or Schmidt).
I wish the Yankees would just bite the bullet and end things once and for all with Giancarlo Stanton. He mucks up the active Roster. He mucks up the 40-Man. He mucks up the club’s payroll. He can no longer run, stay healthy or play baseball. Release him! Let Cruz go!!














As you wrote..."Imagine trying to navigate six innings against Schlittler, Fried, Cole or Rodón, only to face Lagrange, Headrick, Blackburn (or, if you want to dream, Morejón?) and Bednar over the final three. That's an imposing proposition for any opposing lineup, whether in the regular season or the World Series." Except for Lagrange this is almost the same staff as last year..... keeping Fried, Cole and Rodon healthy for the playoffs along with the bullpen will be difficult for NY..... they were gassed by the end of the summer and injured.
Isn't there a Minor League Rule 5 draft, too? And the deal is that the player has to move up one level? So if Facundo is unprotected, wouldn't a team selecting him be able to place him at Double A? And wouldn't that be a no-brainer? Or am I misunderstanding the MiL Rule 5 system?
Stanton is a pretty decent human being and not really mucking up anything at all.
he probably is not going to be able to continue to play for the Yankees..... or any other pro team, but he's mostly harmless.
the organization is likely to be signing a couple of additional free agents, likely to be making a trade or two in which they exchange a pitcher or three for a position player or two.
the sequencing will determine whether they will need to release any player in order to use the roster spot.
Cruz' spot may be available due to injury ....and it might be reasonable to retain an effective relief pitcher, despite age and injury, given the remaining years…
The Yankees have signed Johnny Lasagnya, aka Loaisiga to a 2 year deal with an option for a 3rd. For years, the Yankees couldn't keep this cat healthy, but he leaves, and walla, he's healthy.
I always thought the Yankees would protect Martin or Jace Avina. Martin cam play all 3 OF spots, and is a RHB. With Schuemann & Caballero still here, there is no reason why Ramos is still here except for BC's ego.
I don't get signing Hill at all. I can understand why they didn't protect Facundo, with him not yet even throwing a pitch in AA, and not yet having a real 3rd pitch, and this Pitching Program has no idea how to cultivate relievers.…
Looks like Lasagna is back on the menu.